Plugin Version

3.10.1

Plugin Config

https://hasteb.in/uxocaror.yaml

Server Version

>.... [22:00:40 INFO]: This server is running Tuinity version git-Tuinity-"32ac48d" (MC: 1.15.2) (Implementing API version 1.15.2-R0.1-SNAPSHOT)
>.... [22:00:40 INFO]: Checking version, please wait...
>.... [22:00:40 INFO]: Previous version: git-Tuinity-"6f9ca4f" (MC: 1.15.2)
>.... [22:00:40 INFO]: You are 17 version(s) behind

Server Log

https://hasteb.in/natuyeko.md

What other plugins are you running?

AdvancedWarn, AsyncWorldEdit, AsyncWorldEdit-BountifulAPI*, AuctionHouse, BountifulAPI, BungeeTabListPlus, BuycraftX, ChestShop, Citizens, ClearLag, CommandDoesNotExist, CommandHook, CommandSync*, CoreProtect, CraftBook, CrazyCrates, EditableSign, Essentials, EssentialsGeoIP, EssentialsSpawn, ExtraContexts*, GameModeInventories, GriefPrevention, GSit, Harbor, HolographicDisplays, InventoryRollback, Jobs, KeepDeathDrop, Lasso, LibsDisguises, LimitPillagers, LuckPerms, Matrix, mcMMO, Multiverse-Core, Multiverse-NetherPortals, PlayerParticles, PlayTimeTracker, PlotSquared, PremiumVanish, ProtocolLib, ShopGUIPlus, SkQuery, Skript, skUtilities*, Stress, TempFly, TimeIsMoney*, UltimateTimber, Vault, VeinMiner, Vivecraft-Spigot-Extensions, Votifier, VotingPlugin, Wild, WildStacker, WorldEdit, WorldEditSUI, WorldGuard, WorldGuardExtraFlags

What is happening?

People can create a sell sign even with the sell permissions set to false. ChestShop.shop.create appears to be the only permission it's listening to (even though it does check for the sell perms), which is required to create the buy signs as well.

What did you expect to happen?

I expected an error saying I don't have permission to create the sell sign.

Additional context

LuckPerms verbose: https://luckperms.net/verbose/ENEVfLlenC

I also looked at the FAQ and messing with the perms it was talking about didn't seem to help either

Two things: You are not running the latest development build, please test with that. Also what does your permission setup look like? Iirc you need to negate the create permission and then only grant the ChestShop.shop.create.buy one. (Both sell and buy are children of the general create permission)

What error does a player get when they try it?

They don't have permission to do that

However if I specify an item like "Diamond" on the bottom then it works fine

The auto fill issue should be fixed now, it only checked the create permission if there was no item on the sign before, it now checks the sell and buy permissions separately.

And if you managed to setup your permissions to do what you want then feel free to close the issue. For other errors not directly related to the permissions please then open a new one.

Ah it does actually seem to work by negating the create perm. However, by negating it they can no longer create a sign with ? on the bottom row when the container is empty, even if it's set to buy and not sell
(and yes I'm on the latest dev build now)