CRAFTBOOK-2999 - Reported by Kainzo

Greetings!
This is a bit in-depth, apologies but is very needed :D

I am attempting to make an advancement system where you can use previous gathered items and then combine them to make the "next tier"

In this pastie below, I am combining 3 of RelicPaladinI, 3 of PaladinRelic2, and 3 of PaladinRelic3 - to make PaladinRelic4. However, this is not functioning. I can combine all 1-5 to make the "CodexPaladin" item just fine so multiple items with custom names and lores WORK. However, it doesn't work if there are multiple of the same involved, I believe. I could deal with that, because its kind of confusing and I really just want to add in
http://pastie.org/private/lawdlb0mznq7igjrreankg

Using the RelicNecro crafting - it seems to have odd issues. It can't combine RelicNecro4 x 9 into RelicNecro5 x 1... and the other ones also have issues.

http://pastie.org/private/h69shl5p2vdevasmbdpkjw - the config.
On this config, RelicNecro1 x 3 - does not make RelicNecro2 x 1. However, RelicNecro2 x 3 - makes RelicNecro3 x 1 without an issue.

In summation it seems that if a particular "item-type" is used for a crafting recipes - another item type with different lore/names can't be used to produce its own advancement to its next tier.

RelicNecro1 requires PAPER - however, RelicPaladin1 also requires PAPER and is the only one that works from my entire list (probably because its listed first in the config, to create the next tier on its path)

Also, it seems that it isnt possible to override vanilla recipes using this. I have 9 uniquely named Iron_ingots and it will always craft a block of iron - I figured there was a bug report on this already, just wanted to report it again.

Possible solutions? Make an /assemble - command to bypass some of the workbench issues.
Unsure, it may be bukkit issues but im not certain.

Comment by me4502

It isn't possible to override vanilla recipes with bukkit

You also have 2 definitions called RelicPaladin4, which is why one of those isn't working.

Comment by Kainzo

Thanks for pointing out that copy and paste issue I created. however, it's still not functioning.

RelicNecro1 x3 - still doesn't created RelicNecro2 x 1. My original assumption still holds true. If a custom item name/lore has the same item-type and amount in the recipe as another custom recipe with different name/lore, only the first will be accepted.

I tested this theory, whenever I change the RelicNecro2 recipe to require RelicNecro1 x4 (instead of x3) it works without an issue.

Somewhere in memory its registering the item-type in the recipe and not the item_type + name + lore.
Is there a way to fix this?

Comment by me4502

Bukkit only considers the item type and data value. There is nothing I can do about it in craft book.

Comment by Kainzo

So the only feasible way for me to have this work is if I use different item and data types for each and make sure we dont use the same number... This could get confusing haha..