We use Geyser on our server with bedrock functionality. I've noticed a reoccurring problem where there is no such thing as transparent image frames on mobile. While this is a nuisance, if Yamipa had a way to send itemframes based on player's client, we would be able to make solid pictures for mobile, and transparent for java. Geyser has support for telling if a client is bedrock.

We also noticed where GIF frames update too frequently for mobile, and they will force disconnect. Could there be a way to config gifs to load in fewer frame updates so there isn't packet overload? I haven't been able to use gifs on bedrock unless they're very small.

Hi @Wolvend,

As I've said in other occasions, Minecraft is not in any way designed to place custom images on the world. To achieve this, Yamipa does some weird stuff the game wasn't built to handle.

Minecraft Java Edition and Bedrock are nothing alike, so just dropping Geyser or a similar packet translator won't work. In fact, the issue you mention about the transparent images is even acknowledged by the Geyser developers as a limitation of Bedrock's protocol.

Hi! I think what's being requested here is the ability to send a different image to Bedrock vs Java clients. For example:

Java Client: imgA.gif
Bedrock Client: imgB.png

This would be a really useful feature to deal with the lag associated with GIFs on Bedrock clients. Obviously the /yamipa give command would have to be changed (maybe as simple as adding an optional second image file param - if not specified applies to both java and bedrock), a bit like /yamipa give <player> <img> [bedrock_img] <amount> <width> <height>.

I hope this makes sense.