
Disabling spawnerEnabled still overrides other mods configs files which is configured correctly.
n0itLT opened this issue ยท 10 comments
Describe the bug
I am having this issue where when I disabled the spawn limitation for unknown mobs (for mca reborn and touhou little maid mod) to make them use the configuration file I already configured; however, it does not work because their spawns are not following what I configured them to do so. The villagers spawning when they shouldn't be spawning (I tried using this mod's configuration for multiple mobs but it doesn't state how to properly write multiple mobs, for example ["mca:zombie_villager mca:female_zombie_villager"] to prevent them from spawning in (you want to stop them spawning into your village as if you kill a zombie villager named it'll lower your reputation. I do not know the right format to write multiple mobs' names to not spawn or ignore the customization (still not gonna work being ovrriden). They will continuously spawn and you'll have to kill them unlike how it should be from a spawner block as you can then cure them there. The bigger problem is just not being able to use the default config from other mods for spawning. You can however disable them from their own config files but it defeats the purpose.
To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:
- Disable spawn limitation for unknown mobs.
- Configure the spawn rate within the default mod's configuration.
- Does not work as they spawn too many.
- Unknown format to write multiple lines of mobs to not spawn or ignore optimization and it overrides all the other mods config for the mob.
Expected behavior
Figure how to write multiple mobs within [""], example ["mca:zombie_villager and "mca:female_zombie_villager"] or without said "and" to just a space, lines, and a workaround to not overriding mods that should not be optimized to their configuration file.
Screenshots
https://www.linkpicture.com/q/test_16.png
Debugging
Before reporting a issue please use /aptweaks debug true
to enable debugging and check if there is anything relevant in the debug.log file.
No idea how to debug
Is the issue happening in combination with other mods? (If yes, please provide a full list)
04/06/2022 12:41 AM 207,225 adaptive_performance_tweaks_1.16.5-2.1.0.jar
04/05/2022 01:55 AM 119,745 AdFinders-1.16.5-5.0.11.1-build.0214.jar
03/25/2022 06:19 AM 3,286,177 Adorn-1.14.1+1.16.5-forge.jar
03/25/2022 09:17 AM 87,852 AdPoles-1.16.5-5.0.6.0-build.0177.jar
03/25/2022 08:37 AM 190,902 AdvancementPlaques-1.16.5-1.4.1.jar
04/05/2022 11:29 AM 24,737 AI-Improvements-1.16.5-0.4.0.jar
03/31/2022 01:08 PM 18,135,643 alexsmobs-1.12.1.jar
03/25/2022 03:20 AM 551,039 Aquaculture-1.16.5-2.1.22.jar
04/05/2022 01:58 PM 18,930,870 Aquamirae+2.2+(1.16.5).jar
03/25/2022 03:32 AM 217,624 archers_paradox-1.16.5-1.4.0.1.jar
03/31/2022 07:49 AM 549,025 architectury-1.30.57.jar
03/31/2022 07:50 AM 28,418 areas_1.16.5-2.8.jar
03/25/2022 08:16 AM 254,988 astikorcarts-1.16.5-1.1.1.jar
03/25/2022 09:11 AM 718,155 babyfat-1.0.1.jar
03/25/2022 03:39 AM 23,874 BackTools-1.16.5-10.1.0.jar
03/25/2022 09:10 AM 250,519 balancedflight-mc1.16.5_v1.3.0.jar
03/25/2022 08:15 AM 2,175,212 betteranimalsplus-1.16.5-11.0.5-forge.jar
03/25/2022 03:17 AM 1,402,482 BetterCaves-Forge-1.16.4-1.1.2.jar
03/25/2022 03:31 AM 81,199,992 betterendforge-1.16.5-1.6.3.jar
03/25/2022 03:24 AM 289,307 BetterMineshafts-Forge-1.16.4-2.0.4.jar
03/25/2022 09:28 AM 13,384,164 betterweather-2.0.1.jar
03/25/2022 03:21 AM 336,577 Bountiful-1.16.4-3.3.1.jar
03/25/2022 09:10 AM 2,177,569 BrassAmberBattleTowers-1.16.5-1.6.3.jar
03/25/2022 09:10 AM 62,053 BroomsMod-1.16.5-1.1.1.jar
03/25/2022 03:17 AM 10,314,611 byg-1.3.5.jar
03/25/2022 09:20 AM 273,299 camera-1.16.5-1.0.14.jar
03/25/2022 09:19 AM 322,836 carryon-1.16.5-1.15.5.22.jar
03/31/2022 01:09 PM 9,631,938 Cataclysm-0.16-HotFix.jar
03/25/2022 06:09 AM 2,033,912 cfm-7.0.0pre22-1.16.3.jar
03/25/2022 06:08 AM 1,283,988 chiselsandbits-1.0.63.jar
04/05/2022 11:34 AM 445,708 Chunk+Pregenerator-V1.16-3.2.1.jar
03/25/2022 03:36 AM 482,439 citadel-1.8.1-1.16.5.jar
03/25/2022 06:56 AM 1,458,779 cloth-config-4.14.54-forge.jar
03/27/2022 05:57 AM 963,433 CNB-1.16.3_5-1.2.11.jar
03/25/2022 03:35 AM 1,326,105 cofh_core-1.16.5-1.4.2.9.jar
03/25/2022 03:32 AM 143,299 collective-1.16.5-4.25.jar
03/25/2022 03:32 AM 227,056 comforts-forge-1.16.5-4.0.1.5.jar
04/05/2022 08:27 PM 87,320 CosmeticArmorReworked-1.16.5-v4a.jar
03/25/2022 09:20 AM 37,332 Craftable+Horse+Armour++Saddle-1.16.5-1.7--Forge.jar
03/25/2022 09:12 AM 246,281 curios-forge-1.16.5-4.0.5.3.jar
03/25/2022 08:15 AM 576,443 decorative_blocks-1.16.4-1.7.2.jar
04/03/2022 01:01 PM 27,469 does_it_tick-1.16.5_v2.0.0.jar
03/25/2022 09:20 AM 1,144,133 DoggyTalents-1.16.5-2.1.15.jar
03/25/2022 03:19 AM 778,769 DungeonCrawl-1.16.5-2.3.5.jar
04/05/2022 01:49 PM 5,544,981 DungeonsArise-1.16.5-2.1.49-beta.jar
03/25/2022 03:34 AM 14,746,751 DynamicSurroundings-1.16.5-4.0.5.0.jar
03/25/2022 08:13 AM 200,577 ElenaiDodge2-1.16.X-1.1.0.jar
04/04/2022 12:38 AM 1,644,020 endrem-5.0.2-R-1.16.5.jar
03/25/2022 03:30 AM 1,472,504 enhancedcelestials-2.0.9-1.16.5.jar
03/25/2022 03:34 AM 3,828,854 EpicFightMod-16.5.13.jar
03/25/2022 09:19 AM 1,155,390 FallingTree-1.16.5-2.11.5.jar
03/25/2022 09:21 AM 2,535,453 FarmersDelight-1.16.5-0.5.4.jar
04/05/2022 11:37 AM 20,615 fastbenchminusreplacement-1.4.jar
03/25/2022 03:33 AM 433,759 firstaid-1.9.7.jar
03/25/2022 03:19 AM 7,152 firstjoinmessage_1.16.5-1.3.jar
03/25/2022 08:24 AM 60,656 fishtraps-0.1.3.jar
04/05/2022 01:31 PM 2,270,002 forbidden_arcanus-16.2.3.jar
03/25/2022 09:30 AM 503,348 ForgeEndertech-1.16.5-7.2.2.0-build.0202.jar
03/25/2022 06:13 AM 12,598 ForgivingVoid_1.16.5-5.2.1.jar
04/03/2022 01:11 PM 7,465 FriendlyFire-1.16.5-7.0.5.jar
04/06/2022 01:48 AM 44,027 ftb-backups-2.1.2.2.jar
04/03/2022 01:02 PM 737,811 ftb-chunks-forge-1605.3.2-build.115.jar
04/03/2022 01:07 PM 585,125 ftb-library-forge-1605.3.4-build.90.jar
04/03/2022 01:09 PM 171,679 ftb-teams-forge-1605.2.3-build.40.jar
04/04/2022 12:39 AM 3,431,793 geckolib-forge-1.16.5-3.0.66.jar
03/25/2022 10:59 AM 234,509 gravestone-1.16.5-1.0.7.jar
03/25/2022 03:21 AM 190,249 guardvillagers-1.16.5.1.2.6.jar
03/25/2022 08:23 AM 72,226 HardcoreRevival_1.16.5-6.0.1.jar
03/25/2022 01:35 PM 9,491 healingcampfire_1.16.5-3.3.jar
03/25/2022 03:33 AM 21,314,646 iceandfire-2.1.9-1.16.5.jar
03/25/2022 08:41 AM 65,270 Iceberg-1.16.5-1.0.38.jar
03/25/2022 03:39 AM 596,540 iChunUtil-1.16.5-10.5.2.jar
03/25/2022 04:11 AM 45,677 InsaneLib-1.4.2-mc1.16.5.jar
03/25/2022 06:12 AM 1,461,446 Inspirations-1.16.5-1.2.3.38.jar
03/25/2022 03:34 AM 197,654 InventoryHud_[1.16.2-1.16.5].forge-3.4.1.jar
04/06/2022 01:12 AM 49,966 inventorysorter-1.16.1-18.1.0.jar
03/25/2022 06:25 AM 123,705 InvMove-1.16.3-0.4.6.jar
03/25/2022 03:35 AM 828,677 jei-1.16.5-7.7.1.152.jar
03/25/2022 09:10 AM 5,179 jumpboat-1.16.5-0.1.0.2.jar
04/05/2022 01:54 PM 849,078 Kobolds-1.6.4.jar
03/25/2022 03:39 AM 6,754,655 kotlinforforge-1.17.0-obf.jar
04/06/2022 08:06 AM 0 list.txt
04/06/2022 01:02 AM 339,470 lootr-1.16.5-0.1.12.42.jar
03/25/2022 09:29 AM 499,698 magitekmechs-forge-MC1.16.5-1.0.11.jar
03/25/2022 06:15 AM 806,737 Mantle-1.16.5-1.6.157.jar
03/25/2022 06:55 AM 2,827,808 MedievalCraft-1.16.5-1.18.0.jar
03/25/2022 09:05 AM 2,777,815 Microcosm-1_16_5-1_5_1.jar
03/25/2022 08:14 AM 4,362,185 minecraft-comes-alive-7.0.10-forge.jar
03/25/2022 06:11 AM 156,393 MmmMmmMmmMmm-1.16.5-1.3.1.jar
04/05/2022 06:12 PM 24,390 Morpheus-1.16.5-4.2.70.jar
03/25/2022 08:31 AM 582,832 mostructures-forge-1.2.0-1.16.5.jar
03/25/2022 06:10 AM 13,534,923 mowziesmobs-1.5.22.jar
03/25/2022 03:23 AM 4,738,369 mysticalworld-1.16.5-0.3.6.27.jar
04/05/2022 02:00 PM 5,746,902 Obscuria's+Essentials+2.2+(1.16.5).jar
04/05/2022 01:38 PM 9,228,734 observable-0.2.1-forge.jar
03/27/2022 05:55 AM 1,454,383 pandoras_creatures-1.16.3-2.0.1.jar
03/25/2022 03:22 AM 396,514 Paraglider-1.16.5-1.3.2.7.jar
03/25/2022 03:21 AM 593,114 Patchouli-1.16.4-53.2.jar
03/27/2022 03:18 AM 265,037 polymorph-forge-1.16.5-0.40.jar
03/25/2022 03:35 AM 193,108 ProgressiveBosses-3.4.3-mc1.16.5.jar
03/25/2022 03:36 AM 1,557,189 projectvibrantjourneys-1.16.5-3.2.11.jar
04/04/2022 02:28 PM 1,045,404 Project_MMO-1.16.5-3.67.6.jar
04/04/2022 04:32 PM 423,940 randompatches-2.4.4-forge.jar
03/25/2022 03:30 AM 7,838 randomvillagenames_1.16.5-1.3.jar
03/25/2022 06:14 AM 5,729,856 rats-7.2.0-1.16.5.jar
03/25/2022 03:33 AM 59,750 RealisticTorches-1.16.5-3.1.2.jar
03/25/2022 09:20 AM 98,561 reap-1.16.5-1.0.0.jar
03/31/2022 07:50 AM 5,576,490 repurposed_structures_forge-3.4.7+1.16.5.jar
04/05/2022 01:53 PM 1,808,662 RoRmod-1.1.4.jar
12/08/2021 02:30 AM 11,168,650 RT Addon V2 1.16.jar
03/25/2022 09:17 AM 49,110 scuba-gear-1.16.5-1.0.3.jar
03/25/2022 08:30 AM 218,460 selene-1.16.5-1.9.0.jar
03/25/2022 09:10 AM 206,580 SkyVillage_1.0.0_1.16.5.jar
03/25/2022 01:33 PM 2,400,243 smallships-1.16.5-1.10.1.jar
03/25/2022 09:05 AM 1,391,975 sons-of-sins-1.16.5-1.0.9.jar
03/25/2022 08:24 AM 113,618 spiders-2.0-1.16.4-1.0.4.jar
04/05/2022 01:49 PM 1,542,647 stalwart-dungeons-1.16.5-1.1.7.jar
03/25/2022 08:44 AM 218,290 stoneholm-1.2.2.jar
03/25/2022 03:33 AM 866,307 subwild-1.3.1.jar
03/25/2022 08:21 AM 14,003,305 supplementaries-1.16.5-0.18.4.jar
03/25/2022 06:07 AM 10,927,812 TConstruct-1.16.5-3.3.4.335.jar
03/27/2022 05:43 AM 7,192,742 touhoulittlemaid-1.16.5-1.0.2.jar
03/25/2022 03:32 AM 157,181 towers_of_the_wild-1.16.4-2.0.1.jar
03/25/2022 03:36 AM 346,620 TravelersBackpack-1.16.5-5.4.7.jar
03/25/2022 09:19 AM 87,614 tumbleweed-1.16-0.4.9.jar
03/25/2022 03:31 AM 276,337 twoplayersonehorse-1.16.4-2.0.2.jar
03/25/2022 04:11 AM 608,118 valhelsia_core-16.0.15.jar
03/25/2022 03:30 AM 1,540,395 valhelsia_structures-1.16.5-0.1.6.jar
03/25/2022 03:31 AM 11,874 villagernames_1.16.5-3.4.jar
03/25/2022 03:33 AM 5,019 villagespawnpoint_1.16.5-1.8.jar
03/31/2022 10:45 PM 5,079,846 voicechat-forge-1.16.5-2.2.31.jar
03/25/2022 03:32 AM 84,528 walljump-forge-1.16.4-1.3.7.jar
03/25/2022 08:38 AM 391,529 WaveyCapes-forge-1.0.4-mc1.16.5.jar
03/25/2022 03:35 AM 375,934 Waystones_1.16.5-7.6.4.jar
03/27/2022 05:55 AM 4,967,448 Wyrmroost-1.16.3-1.2.11.jar
03/25/2022 03:21 AM 106,058 YungsApi-1.16.4-Forge-13.jar
Additional context
Add any other context about the problem here.
Thanks for your report.
You can add multiple mobs separated by a ,
like ["aquaculture:acacia_fish_mount", "aquaculture:arapaima", ...]
.
I will add a better example in the config to make this clear.
In general the deny_list blocks all spawns of these mobs regardless if they have a custom name or not.
The spawnLimitationEnabled on the other hand is only reducing the spawn of mobs without a custom name.
According your list you have "villagernames" installed, so each villiager (including zombie villiager) will have a custom name and will be ignored by the "spawnLimitationEnabled" but will not ignored by the "spawnDenyList".
If mca is not offering an option to block these, I'm happy to add an additional options for these in the config.
Performance wise I recommended if an mod offering to disable specific types to use this option instead of the "spawnDenyList".
I will look at it later, thank you. Will have to do a lot of testing if that's the case.
You are amazing, thank you for the help; however, regarding the other mod's config of controlling their chances of spawning. They don't seem to come to effect and over-spawn. If I disable it within those other mod's config it does work, just the spawn chances.
You could try to enable the debug mode, just use the following command in the chat on the server: /aptweaks debug true
This enables the debug mode, let it run for 5 minutes or so and than disable it again with /aptweaks debug false
.
This will create a "debug.log" file in your Minecraft log folder which includes all kind of information why a specific spawn was allowed or denied.
If you unable to read the file, feel free to share it and I will take a look if I see anything strange here.
Thanks for the update. First of all the mod is not spawning any kind of mob by itself.
It's basically checks if an entity should be restricted and restricts the spawn, but it is not spawning any entity by itself.
This means if you have normal mobs in the nether, it has nothing to do with this mod.
Could you please let me know which kind of "mobs" you have in the nether?
Unfortunately I see only one valid log but without /aptweaks debug true
with the following entries:
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.635] [Server thread/WARN] [APTweaks:SpawnConfigManager/]: There are known issue with the rats mod and spawn control, please not report any issue!
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.636] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnConfigManager/]: Clearing spawn rates calculation ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.637] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnConfigManager/]: Enable pre-calculate entity spawn rates for Players and World
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.638] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnConfigManager/]: Optimize Passive Mobs: true
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.638] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnConfigManager/]: Optimize Neutral Mobs: true
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.639] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnConfigManager/]: Optimize Hostile Mobs: true
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.639] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnConfigManager/]: Optimize Boss Mobs: true
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.640] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable special mobs spawn rate control for Minecraft and 6 mobs with: {minecraft:the_nether:minecraft:wither_skeleton=10, minecraft:the_nether:minecraft:piglin_brute=20, minecraft:the_nether:minecraft:zombified_piglin=20, minecraft:the_nether:minecraft:piglin=20, minecraft:the_end:minecraft:enderman=40, minecraft:the_nether:minecraft:skeleton=20}
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.641] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable passive mobs spawn rate control for Minecraft and 1 mobs with maxPerPlayer:2 and maxPerWorld:16 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.641] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable neutral mobs spawn rate control for Minecraft and 24 mobs with maxPerPlayer:4 and maxPerWorld:12 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.642] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable hostile mobs spawn rate control for Minecraft and 36 mobs with maxPerPlayer:4 and maxPerWorld:12 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.643] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable passive mobs spawn rate control for Minecraft (water) and 4 mobs with maxPerPlayer:2 and maxPerWorld:16 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.645] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable neutral mobs spawn rate control for Minecraft (water) and 2 mobs with maxPerPlayer:2 and maxPerWorld:16 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.646] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable passive mobs spawn rate control for Alex's Mobs and 10 mobs with maxPerPlayer:3 and maxPerWorld:8 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.646] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable neutral mobs spawn rate control for Alex's Mobs and 19 mobs with maxPerPlayer:3 and maxPerWorld:8 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.647] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable hostile mobs spawn rate control for Alex's Mobs and 17 mobs with maxPerPlayer:2 and maxPerWorld:10 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.647] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable passive mobs spawn rate control for Aquaculture 2 and 40 mobs with maxPerPlayer:5 and maxPerWorld:16 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.648] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable hostile mobs spawn rate control for Ice and Fire and 19 mobs with maxPerPlayer:4 and maxPerWorld:32 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.649] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable boss mobs spawn rate control for Ice and Fire and 6 mobs with maxPerPlayer:2 and maxPerWorld:4 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.666] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable neutral mobs spawn rate control for Mowzies Mobs and 1 mobs with maxPerPlayer:2 and maxPerWorld:64 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.682] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable hostile mobs spawn rate control for Mowzies Mobs and 7 mobs with maxPerPlayer:2 and maxPerWorld:16 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.682] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable boss mobs spawn rate control for Mowzies Mobs and 3 mobs with maxPerPlayer:1 and maxPerWorld:8 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.683] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable passive mobs spawn rate control for Rats and 2 mobs with maxPerPlayer:4 and maxPerWorld:54 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.684] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable hostile mobs spawn rate control for Rats and 5 mobs with maxPerPlayer:3 and maxPerWorld:12 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.685] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable boss mobs spawn rate control for Rats and 1 mobs with maxPerPlayer:2 and maxPerWorld:8 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.685] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable passive mobs spawn rate control for Supplementaries and 1 mobs with maxPerPlayer:2 and maxPerWorld:16 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.686] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks/]: ? Enable hostile mobs spawn rate control for Tinkers Construct and 1 mobs with maxPerPlayer:4 and maxPerWorld:16 ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:14.687] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnConfigManager/]: Added 199 player spawn rules, 199 world spawn rules and 6 special spawn rules.
...
[08Apr2022 01:34:19.997] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnManager/]: Allow List: []
[08Apr2022 01:34:19.998] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnManager/]: Deny List: [mca:female_zombie_villager, mca:male_zombie_villager]
[08Apr2022 01:34:19.999] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnManager/]: ? Enable limiter and block randomly every 10 unknown mob from spawning ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:20.000] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnManager/]: ? Enable spawn rate control with max 64 per world ...
[08Apr2022 01:34:20.001] [Server thread/INFO] [APTweaks:SpawnManager/]: ? Enable spawn rate control with max 10 per player ...
This means it expected to have a higher number of the following mobs in the nether:
- minecraft:the_nether:minecraft:wither_skeleton=10
- minecraft:the_nether:minecraft:piglin_brute=20
- minecraft:the_nether:minecraft:zombified_piglin=20
- minecraft:the_nether:minecraft:piglin=20
- minecraft:the_end:minecraft:enderman=40
- minecraft:the_nether:minecraft:skeleton=20
But again the mod is not adding an additional spawns, so if you see mobs spawn, which shouldn't it's not related to this mod.
I am seeing a bunch of normal zombies, rats (rats mod), bats, other hostile, and witches spawning into the nether.
Thanks for the update, unfortunately the Rats mod and Better End are not 100% compatible with this mod:
https://github.com/MarkusBordihn/BOs-Adaptive-Performance-Tweaks/blob/1.16.5/README.md#-unsupported-mods
Because of the way (core modification / mixins) the mods are spawning mobs, adaptive performance tweaks it's not able to accurate handle / block the spawns. This means it's expected that you see this kinds of mobs with the installed mods.
Unfortunately if you have issue with mobs from incompatible mods there is nothing I could do from my side and it's not related to this mod itself.