Alfheim Lighting Engine

Alfheim Lighting Engine

715k Downloads

Stairs next to stairs still exhibit incorrect shadow behavior (more obvious when smooth lighting is turned off)

ninjakitty844 opened this issue ยท 7 comments

commented

Describe the bug

2023-09-14_22 25 56

2023-09-14_22 30 44

Reproducibility

Please try to reproduce the issue with as few other mods as possible. Then check one of the following checkboxes according to your results. To check a checkbox, replace the space between the square brackets with an x (like this [x]) or create the issue and check the checkbox by clicking on it.

  • I reproduced this issue with as few other mods as possible installed. (only Red Core, MixinBooter, ConfigAnytime, Valkyrie, and Alfheim)
  • I am unable to reproduce this issue consistently.

To Reproduce

  1. Put stairs in a pattern similar to the ones shown in my screenshots

Expected behavior

I think most stair lighting issues would be solved if stairs were prevented from blocking light under all circumstances, I believe that is how modern versions of Minecraft handle stairs.

commented

I have the same issue
without the mod
2024-03-04_15 06 48
with the mod
2024-03-04_15 11 34

commented

I have the same issue without the mod 2024-03-04_15 06 48 with the mod 2024-03-04_15 11 34

Oh yeah that's really not right, I will try to take a look.

commented

Also experiencing issues with stairs.
image
Oh, it also affects slabs but I don't have a screenshot of that atm.

commented

would be solved if stairs were prevented from blocking light under all circumstances
That would literally prevent them from being used as a roof

would be solved if stairs were prevented from blocking light under all circumstances
No

Concerning how to fix this there probably is a way but it isn't my priority to work on this issue, everything I can think of as drawbacks.
Also, this is with smooth lighting off, smooth lighting on probably fixes the issue anyway

commented

And mooth lighting only hides the problem a little bitz you can still tell the issue is there with it.

commented

Might be that modern stairs only block light on their bottom side and none of the other sides.

idk exactly how it works, but I'd look to modern MC to see how they fixed the issue.

commented

Might be that modern stairs only block light on their bottom side and none of the other sides.

That would not fix the issues you showed