Applied Energistics 2

Applied Energistics 2

Mods
160M Downloads

Broken white bed recipe when crafting with the Crafting on a Stick mod

antiphysika opened this issue ยท 3 comments

commented

Describe the bug

When trying to craft a white bed as below, the recipe appears broken and offers slabs as the result instead of the expected bed item.

How to reproduce the bug

  1. Use the crafting_on_a_stick:crafting_table
  2. Place white wool in middle three slots
  3. Place birch planks in bottom three slots

Expected behavior

One gets a bed instead of slabs

Additional details

First encountered on a server and reproduced using the two-mod instance in singleplayer. Not tried any other recipes to see if any others are broken.

This is all with NeoForge 21.0.20-beta, AE2 19.0.4-alpha and Crafting on a Stick 1.21.0.0.

Wasn't sure if that was a bug in Crafting on a Stick or AE2, hopefully I've not targetted the wrong GitHub!

Which minecraft version are you using?

1.21

On which mod loaders does it happen?

NeoForge

Crash log

https://gist.github.com/antiphysika/f8914bf36d31053464d79beefe0edb54

commented

In your crash log FacadeRecipe plays a role as well. That might be a duplicate of #7951. You did not mention a crash though. Is that related to your problem?

I could not reproduce your original problem in the way you described. You could try to remove either mod and see if it can be attributed to a specific mod. Also the order in which blocks are placed into the grid could be relevant. Could you be more specific, which block was placed where and in what order? You mention the crafting_on_a_stick:crafting_table. Does it happen only there or are crafting terminals or regular vanilla crafting tables affected as well?

What I could produce is a duplicate of #7951 that happens when you place 3 planks in the bottom row and then place a wool in the center slot. That also happens without the crafting_on_a_stick mod.

commented

Apologies, I was far too shattered when I filed.

To clarify, there was no crash in my case. I tested a fair few times in both singleplayer and on a server to make sure it was reliably reproduceable and the worst that came about was the broken recipe with the accompanying IndexOutOfBoundsException stack splat on the console.

Quickly testing a few things just now, I can't reproduce with just the Crafting on a Stick mod. I also can't reproduce with the vanilla crafting table.

I'll dig deeper, record my steps in more detail and report back.

commented

Bafflingly, I can't reproduce this anymore using the exact versions of NeoForge, AE2 and Crafting on a Stick I was able to reproduce this in singleplayer on the first attempt only yesterday. I even tried out all NF versions from current (.21) down to .18 just in case but that made no difference.

The only thing I haven't been able to try is rolling back the server instance I first hit this on, but that'll be a larger undertaking that I won't be able to get to until tonight (~9 or so hours from now).