Issue Description

In reference to Issue #201 I tried the procedure myself.
With the script implemented in Attempt 5 it failed, and carried over to all recipes with NBT Data in the script.

What Happens

Upon entering a valid recipe, the output isn't ready to be taken.
Step 1. Install the script
Step 2. Start Minecraft
Step 3. Go into a world
Step 4. Place the the engineering table down
Step 5. Place the ingredients in the correct order (Or use JEI)
Step 6. Watch as madness unfolds

For further Madness follow these Steps

Step 8. Leave the recipe inside the table
Step 9. Restart the game
Step 10. Take the now craftable Item out of the table
Step 11. Put the recipe into the table again
Step 12. Same as Step 6

I have a video of the steps 9 to 12

What You Expect to Happen

That the recipes doesn't fail to work.

Script

https://hastebin.com/mivopacevu.xml

The latter works, the first does not.

Affected Versions

Do not use latest; please supply accurate version numbers.

• Minecraft: 1.12.2
• Forge: 1.12.2-forge1.12.2-14.23.5.2838
• CraftTweaker: 1.12-4.1.20
• Artisan Worktables: 1.12.2-1.22.15
• Athenaeum: 1.12.2-1.17.4

Works:
/give @p thermalinnovation:saw 1 0 {Energy: 0, Mode: 1}

Does NOT work:
/give @p thermalinnovation:saw 1 0 {Energy: 1, Mode: 1}
/give @p thermalinnovation:saw 1 0 {Energy: 20000, Mode: 1}
/give @p thermalinnovation:saw 1 0 {Energy: 40000, Mode: 1}

Thank you so much!!!

Using the steps you provided, I was able to reproduce the issue and use it as a place to start debugging.

I have determined that it is the act of viewing the recipe in JEI that causes it to stop working for any NBT values other than {Energy: 0, Mode: 1}. I suspect that there is a flaw in AW's code that allows JEI to operate directly on recipe ingredients instead of a copy of the ingredients.

RecipeBuilder.get("engineer")
  .setShapeless([<thermalinnovation:saw>])
  .addOutput(<minecraft:dirt>)
  .create();

Here are my results:

1. Disable vanilla crafting for the Engineer's Worktable
2. Load game and world
3. Place Engineer's Worktable
4. Place thermalinnovation:saw.withTag({Energy: 40000, Mode: 1}) in any slot
5. Extract output
6. Confirm recipe works
7. Place thermalinnovation:saw.withTag({Energy: 40000, Mode: 1}) in any slot
8. Confirm recipe works
9. Remove saw item
10. !!--> View the recipe in JEI
11. Place thermalinnovation:saw.withTag({Energy: 40000, Mode: 1}) in any slot
12. Confirm recipe no longer works
13. Break the table
14. Place a new table
15. Place thermalinnovation:saw.withTag({Energy: 40000, Mode: 1}) in anyslot
16. Confirm recipe no longer works
17. Remove saw item
18. Place thermalinnovation:saw.withTag({Energy: 0, Mode: 1}) in middle slot
19. Confirm recipe works

The recipe continues to behave improperly until the game is reloaded.

Glad to be helping, tell me what to do next if you need it. (or ping me on discord Silvanus_Hunter)

Should be fixed in 1.22.16

Current Possible Workaround:

add to the Item in question (Saw or else) a .withTag({}) condition.

Script to confirm that this works:

https://hastebin.com/tomoralesa.xml

The Saw still doesn't work, but the magnet (also with a rf nbt powertag) works when adding the .withTag({}) condition.