Better Combat [Fabric & Forge]

Better Combat [Fabric & Forge]

Mods
25M Downloads

[Forge] Putting Two-Handed in the off hand will disappear

Dr-WeiAL opened this issue · 7 comments

commented

Minecraft version - 1.20.1
Mod loader - NeoForge 47.1.65
Mod version - 1.7.3
I am using the latest version available - yes

Describe the bug
As the title says.
Putting Two-Handed in the off hand will disappear.

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Take the Two-Handed weapon.
  2. Use "F" or any method to put it in the off hand.
  3. Weapons are gone.
  4. Open Inventory at this time and you'll see that it's on the off hand, but it doesn't show up
  5. If you keep pressing "F", the previous weapon will disappear.

Expected behavior
It shouldn't go away.

Screenshots or video recordings
1

Additional context
If you need to test it, you can try the following mods
https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/l2weaponry
https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/l_ender-s-cataclysm

commented

Hello!
There are 2 known solutions for that problem.

  • Do not use newer version than Forge 47.1.3 (use the officially recommended version), new versions are broken 🙂
  • If using Apugli and TooManyOrigins mods, make sure to update them

image

commented

That means, the modloader itself introduced breaking changes.
Use the recommended version, or experiment with unstable version on your own behalf.

commented

That means the problem is unsolvable?
Some of the mods I added require a higher version of Forge than 47.1.3, so the first solution could not be used
These two mods don't have a 1.20.1 version of Forge, so the second solution can't be used either

commented

Oh well, I was misremembering, I didn't add a mod that requires a higher version of Forge than 47.1.3, so let's just go with the first option

commented

As a heads up, this is still an issue with Forge 47.2.0, the currently recommended forge version, as well as Forge 47.2.1.

commented

Forge broke its own API and internal behaviour without considering whether or not mods will continue to work, then started recommending the new broken version.
I have no capacity to babysit the problems Forge creates for itself.
Forge support will likely end right here.

NeoForge support will likely replace it.

commented

Fixed by Better Combat 1.8.0 for Forge. Requires Forge at least 47.2.0