Just the title, I have a few mods along with it that I doubt will cause this issue: Thaumcraft, Botania, Blood Magic, Inventory tweaks, and JEI.
This is with the most recent version of Bewitchment.

After testing some more (it was when I died to sun damage), I can't seem to recreate it.

Did you try this on the latest commit? I reworked the capability almost completely