Hello,

With forge-1.7.10-10.13.0.1197 and biomesoplenty-1.7.10-2.1.0.961, I observed the following quirks:

Redwood saplings will not grow in a 3x3 or 1x1 in any biome, including redwood forest. The sapling will occasionally change to a sacred oak sapling on a tick and then back to a redwood sapling.

Willow saplings will grow, but the bottom block is replaced by a mangrove sapling when the tree grows, which then "pops off" the dirt, leaving an empty block

Mangrove saplings will plant, but "pop off" the sand when growth is triggered. Can provide screens if needed.

Thanks for the great mod!

Edit - I was unable to get the willow sapling issue to repeat, so unsure what caused it.
I did notice, however, that the palm sapling will not grow on dirt or podzol (this may be intentional), and when planted on grass, the trunk will "grow" from a block directly adjacent to the sapling (also may be intentional)

Still occurring in 1.7.10-2.1.0.1387

Does "closed" mean "fixed"?

I can confirm the willow tree / mangrove sapling bug still exists in BoP 2.1.0.1067

I'll have a look at everything else mentioned when I get the chance, however I will note, Redwood saplings require at least a 4x4 with 40ish blocks above them free in order to grow.

Saplings are certainly one thing that are in need of a cleanup

Thanks for the info on the redwood sapling. I'll mess around with it some more to see if I can get one to grow.

To add to this issue, when I place pine saplings down, the game occasionally changes them to sacred oak saplings.

Nevermind, it turned out to be an issue with Forge.

What was the issue with Forge? I am unable to get any saplings to grow even with bonemeal on 1.7.10.