Botania Unofficial

Botania Unofficial

794k Downloads

Crash on joining server

robaimes opened this issue ยท 9 comments

commented

This issue is extremely minor and probably would not be widely come across. Basically, having Botania installed client side and trying to connect to a server that does not have it installed will result in a crash.

As I said, an uncommon occurrence. But, as an example, modpacks distributing through ATLauncher have 'Optional mods'. A server may not chose to install this, but a player might have done. This is an instance where this issue would occur.

Relevant mod versions:

  • forge-1.10.2-12.18.1.2065-universal
  • jei_1.10.2-3.9.0.245
  • Botania-unofficial.r1.8-316
commented

As I said, a minor issue. but it is an issue that users would encounter in the scenario I outlined.

But I don't recall other mods having this behavior.

commented

Well, true. I recall joining a vanilla server with TheOneProbe without crashing.

Back to the topic.

It might be a JEI - Botania - Client Side issue, maybe due to items being available client side? Cause you won't be able to use the mods, and will give A LOT of isues

commented

That's why it's been reported to both sides, as per the OP there is an open issue on the JEI repo.

commented

I saw xD

commented

Well.. Why would you install a mod that the server doesn't have?
You won't be able to use said mod anyways soo

commented

Usercase:

Install a modpack with over 250 mods, 100+ are optionals
You have access to 5 different servers, some have Botania, some dont.
All variants of the same modpacks, just different optionals enabled / / disabled

commented

Well, still.. I don't think this can be classified as a "bug". Make more instances for each server.

commented

MultiMC would help you for this

commented

Not sure what the best solution is here, and it's such a niche case.

FML should be blocking you from connecting so it might even be an issue there.

If anyone has ideas hit up the forge or botania v2 repos