Hitboxes do not line up with flowers
Opened this issue · 11 comments
@Vazkii decided to make each functional flower appear in different spaces on a block rather than centering them—probably for some realistic variety—and that’s fine and all, but the hitboxes do not line up with the flowers, which is extremely annoying when trying to break flowers, using the manaseer monocle, or using the wand of the forest.
This has been posted before (#2172), but it was closed, even though the issue has not been fixed. Apparently, as @williewillus mentioned, this bug has been fixed in the 1.11.2 version of Botania (which I cannot verify), but lots of people still use 1.10.2, and its modding community is much larger; therefore, it would be fantastic if this were fixed for the 1.10.2 version, too!
By the way, I also use OptiFine; I’m unsure whether that’s what’s causing the issue like it was mentioned in #2172.
Screenshot
Versions
Minecraft version: 1.10.2
Botania version: r1.9-341
OptiFine version: HD U D7
Forge version: 12.18.3.2272
Quoting myself here:
This has been posted before (#2172), but it was closed, even though the issue has not been fixed. Apparently, as @williewillus mentioned, this bug has been fixed in the 1.11.2 version of Botania (which I cannot verify), but lots of people still use 1.10.2, and its modding community is much larger; therefore, it would be fantastic if this were fixed for the 1.10.2 version, too!
Why did @Vazkii only fix this in the 1.11.2 version? Lots of people still use the 1.10.2 version.
this isn't gamebreaking* and at the moment making releases for previous mc versions breaks the build number ordering
*=in fact it was a bug with vanilla flowers from 1.7 through 1.11 and no one seemed to care :P
Er, all right. I understand that it shouldn’t be prioritized, since there are probably other bugs that are way worse than this which should be fixed first, but I don’t understand what you mean by “break[ing] the build number ordering.”
Why did @Vazkii only fix this in the 1.11.2 version? Lots of people still use the 1.10.2 version.
Again this is vanilla bug therefore it was fixed by mojang in 1.11, not vazkii. From the wiki:
*Flowers: Their hitbox now corresponds to their exact visual location on the block (as opposed to always placed in the middle of the block).
It also needs some fixing on my end which needs a forge fix to fully take effect. Keeping this open till then
@williewillus
Firstly, I thought that this was a vanilla bug; why would Forge fix a Minecraft bug?
Secondly, 2292 is for 1.11, and it was fixed in 1.11, so why would Forge fix a bug that’s already fixed?
I want this annoying bug fixed in 1.10.2.
this isn't caused by one bug, it's caused by a vanilla bug and a forge bug together. Vanilla one got fixed in 1.11.0. Forge one only got fixed in 2292. Neither of those are 1.10.2 :P
like I said, this shouldn't be gamebreaking, I don't know what else to say because both the parts required for the fix are not in 1.10