Version Information

Forge version: forge-14.23.4.2757
Botania version: botania r1.10-354.jar

Further Information

Link to crash log: N/A

Steps to reproduce:

1. Open Flower Pouch
2. Insert flowers into flower pouch
3. Open another inventory GUI. So far the Creative inventory or opening a backpack manage to trigger this effect
4. Close the other GUI and open the flower pouch once more

What I expected to happen: The flower pouch should have as many flowers as I put in.

What happened instead: All the flowers are erased from the flower pouch and all the counters display a red “0”

Same thing here, I'm not sure what is causing it but I'm also on a server. I was using my flowers for their petals but I know I didnt use them all. i was only using black and brown and I had some purple. Everything is gone.

I can't get this to happen, are you on a server?

It seems to only happen on servers. Even then, it doesn't happen all the time. It may be more common with more flowers in the bag. It also happens to the bauble box.

does it only happen in creative mode? that has known issues in forge with deleting item capabilities (the thing that stores inventories)

No, this was happening on a server in survival mode in my case.

I just noticed this happened to me today as well. Went to go make some stuff, and all my flowers are gone. I have died a few times since I last used my flower pouch, so not entirely sure if this was the gravestone mod dropping the data or just the flowers randomly disappearing. I am running my own server. I will see if I can identify the cause.

I just noticed this happened to me as well, though in my case I'm not sure what triggered it. It was on a Forge + spongeforge server (is anyone else using sponge?), and although I might have used creative mode at some point, I don't think it was reason enough to explain my pouch's data being cleared. Why does this only seems to happen with flower pouches and bauble cases from this mod? Does no one else implement capability NBT for their metadata? If they do, might checking what they do differently... In the meantime, I'm switching to /Dank/Null for my floral storage needs.

I am not using Sponge. Also, Immersive Engineering Toolboxes are confirmed affected by an underlying Forge issue, which Forge says is a vanilla Minecraft issue. Backpacks! definitely does not seem affected by these issues though, and I have no clue how its storing inventory contents. It's not in NBT data- all that's there is a UUID.

yeah, storing stuff in capability nbt has been a pain all along. I'll move it back to the regular stack NBT in 1.14.

Sorry to revive this post but was curious. Is this fix something we can hope to see for previous versions? 1.12.2 Specifically?

This issue is stale because it has been open for a while with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed soon.

Potentially related to the issues with Forge described in #2408? One of my players also reported this happening to her Bauble case and Flower Pouch and she has switched to using Backpacks to store the items to ensure it doesn't keep happening.

I believe this and #1894 are the same issue. I'm also having this problem in 1.12.2, with creative, Thermal Expansion satchels, and inventory sorting, and would absolutely love a backport for the fix.

Duplicate of #1894