Botania

Botania

133M Downloads

Mystical flowers aren't compostable

00-Steven opened this issue ยท 1 comments

commented

Mod Loader

Both Fabric and Forge (I confirm that I have tested both loaders and will specify both loader versions below)

Minecraft Version

1.19.2

Botania version

yea

Modloader version

.

Modpack info

No response

The latest.log file

.

Issue description

Mystical flowers aren't compostable, but're supposed to be.

Steps to reproduce

No response

Other information

Was told to make an issue as reminder to implement such.

commented

Some thoughts.

Things that probably should be compostable:

  • petals
  • petal blocks
  • small mystical flowers
  • tall mystical flowers
  • shimmering mushrooms
  • cellular blocks

I think as soon as non-organic ingredients (dyes can probably count as organic) come into play, the flower should probably no longer be compostable, that is: glimmering, floating or special flowers should probably not go into composters for various reasons.

Relations between composting chances:

  • small flowers make 2 petals
  • large flowers make 4 petals
  • petal blocks are crafted from 9 petals
  • shimmering mushrooms are used as petal replacements in recipes

Petals work a lot like seeds for tall mystical flowers, but also petal blocks are crafted from more petals than two tall or four small flowers produce.

Vanilla similarities:

  • 30% category: (dried) kelp, seeds, pink petals, saplings, grass/fern
  • 50% category: dried kelp block, tall grass/fern, cactus
  • 65% category: flowers (small and tall), mushrooms, moss block, unprocessed harvested items (potato, wheat, etc.)
  • 85% category: processed harvested items (baked potato, break, cookies, hay bale)
  • 100% category: highly processed food items (cake, pumpkin pie)

Reasoning for likely categories:

  • It probably makes sense to treat mystical flowers the same as regular flowers, i.e. put them into the 65% category.
  • Vanilla crafting typically reduces the combined composting effect, so petals are probably fine to put into the 30% category.
  • If the same treatment as for kelp is applied, that would mean petal blocks go into the 50% category, making them highly inefficient, compared to composting the flowers directly.
  • Considering that cellular blocks are mostly made from cactus, but also have about one crop product (beetroot, carrot, potato) in them, they might go into the 85% category.