port to neoforge?
VaporeonScripts opened this issue · 17 comments
will the mod ever get ported to neoforge 1.21.1? as im unable to publish my modpack with sinytra connector and fabric version of continuity
Sorry, could you please add the NeoForge tag to your mod on CurseForge so that NeoForge modpacks can use it with Sinytra Connector on CurseForge?
I fully support this, this mod is needed for neoforge as i still havent found a worthwhile working replacement for connective textures on neoforge, i hope this gets looked at! i would be ok with either a sinytra connector port or native neoforge port, whatever the devs prefer to do to get this ported i would fully support.
Yes, very agree, neoforge has been getting more and more popular since 1.21.1, but there is no similar mod that works well yet, so we need it！
Yes, very agree, neoforge has been getting more and more popular since 1.21.1, but there is no similar mod that works well yet, so we need it！
Especially since sodium has an official neoforge port now, it would be much easier for them to port to neoforge i think.
Continuity already works well when used with Connector. What advantages would a standalone NeoForge jar have?
Continuity already works well when used with Connector. What advantages would a standalone NeoForge jar have?
i find that connector is unreliable and buggy, as well as it being beta software more generally, i dont think it is a good idea to rely on it for neoforge support, i have personally had stability issues and bugs with connector with compatibility with other mods, having a native neoforge port would allievate these issues.
currently using it for continuity, never had an issue, altough a direct neoforge port would be better to have less mods installed and less conflicts :D
The easiest way for me to make a NeoForge jar right now would be to bundle the parts of Connector that Continuity needs to work in the jar (what you call a "sinytra connector port"). While this bundled part of Connector would be simpler than all of Connector, I don't know if that would necessarily help with compatibility. A standalone jar also makes me responsible for any issues that arise, which include issues in Connector's code that I can't fix.
well yeah thats why i recommended a native port, sinytra connector isnt stable and imo isnt a reliable mod to rely on for mod compat for neoforge, its beta software and has lots of issues and i have ran into issues where fabric mods on sinytra dont work together with neoforge mods bc of incompatibilities between the 2 modloaders n stuff, sadly it just doesnt work all that well sadly, it would probably be much more reliable long term and simpler to just do a native neoforge port than trying to get it to work on sinytra
u said it urself about the issues in sinytra that u cant fix with continuity, theres bound to be more and more issues with sinytra that pile up as the project progresses and keeps trying to make more compatibility with upstream, and the same issue persists whether u make a seperate jar file for sinytra or not, so its more reliable to do a neoforge native port honestly
thats just my 2 cents tho, plus sinytra is too complex for the average user and i wouldnt recommend it to anyone for ppl who want stable modpacks
A native port requires significantly more time and effort to both make initially and maintain later. I do not currently have the time for this.
A native port requires significantly more time and effort to both make initially and maintain later. I do not currently have the time for this.
well i mean no pressure ofc, not trying to put pressure on u to do it, mb if i was, do it at ur own pace ofc, if u dont currently have time for a neoforge port then hopefully someone else whos smarter than me can do a neoforge port or something
Sorry, could you please add the NeoForge tag to your mod on CurseForge so that NeoForge modpacks can use it with Sinytra Connector on CurseForge?
I second this, this is exactly my problem atm, I can't upload my mod pack, it always gets rejected because its only missing the NeoForge Tag, even tho with the "Forgified Fabric API" makes it work without any issues.
Just upload the same version as Alpha and NeoForge Tag on it, this way people won't be downloading it for Fabric but it will still work with modpacks.
