Controllable (Forge)

Controllable (Forge)

4M Downloads

Reproducible crash under Linux with the xbox one controller

Volker-Weissmann opened this issue ยท 26 comments

commented

Hi, Minecraft keeps crashing with the following message:

The game crashed whilst initializing game
Error: java.lang.IllegalStateException: GLFW error before init: [0x10004]Invalid button in gamepad mapping 050000005e040000fd02000003090000 (Xbox One Wireless Controller)
Log file:
crash-2020-02-22_22.00.07-client.txt

My System:
OS: Arch Linux
Java: openjdk 13.0.2 2020-01-14
Forge version: 1.15.2-31.1.0
I'm using the xbox one controller via bluetooth

commented

Can reproduce here as well. Works fine on Windows.

commented

As a workaround, I believe the xpadneo driver or xow project both located on Github do not exhibit this behavior.

commented

This is a driver issue, not my mod.

commented

Unfortunately, the two drivers aforementioned have not fixed the issue. Looking at the stack trace, it would seem that either GLFW or LWJGL are responsible. I'm on 1.15.2, on Arch, connected to the controller via Bluetooth.

commented

Do you have a link to the drivers issue?

commented

I'm not sure what you mean by that. By 'issue', I meant this issue here. Although if its not the mod, I'm not sure what the cause is.

commented

No, i just meant that I tried using the two controller drivers mentioned before, and rebooting to make sure it had installed, to no avail. Its a bit odd...

commented

You said that

Unfortunately, the two drivers aforementioned have not fixed the issue.

So I assumed that you opened an issue in the bugtrackers of GLFW or LWJGL.

commented

Ok. I think I will just continue using Mouse+Keyboard

commented

This issue should be reopened. I can reproduce on Pop OS and the drivers did not fix anything

commented

Even if I reopen, I can't do anything because the report points to GLFW. I recommend just switching to a different controller if you have the option.

commented

Even if I reopen, I can't do anything because the report points to GLFW. I recommend just switching to a different controller if you have the option.

Oddly enough, this issue does not happen while wired. I will double check the stacktrace later

commented

Even if I reopen, I can't do anything because the report points to GLFW. I recommend just switching to a different controller if you have the option.

Oddly enough, this issue does not happen while wired. I will double check the stacktrace later

Same here, it works if I use a cable.

commented

I know the previous entries have said they tried the drivers, but the symptoms (crash, works wired) describe the issue I've also encountered when using the standard Linux driver. I would double check that you're truly using xpadneo (will rumble on start) or xow (if using wireless adapter). I haven't used xpadneo in several months, but it worked well when I did and I definitely know xow works.

commented

I'm using xpadneo, as I connect to my controller via Bluetooth. Haven't tried wired yet, will give that a go later on today. I can't see the standard Linux driver loaded into the kernel.

commented

I know the previous entries have said they tried the drivers, but the symptoms (crash, works wired) describe the issue I've also encountered when using the standard Linux driver. I would double check that you're truly using xpadneo (will rumble on start) or xow (if using wireless adapter). I haven't used xpadneo in several months, but it worked well when I did and I definitely know xow works.

I tried both, xpadneo does the rumble. Not sure what xow is supposed to do but I got a small vibration different from xpadneo. Is there a way to check if I'm still hooked into the standard Linux drivers?

commented

Hey guys, I'm on OpenSUSE Tumbleweed and the controller virtual mouse controls the "real" courser as well.
I'm using a XBox One Controller with the xow driver.

Can someone confirm this issue?

commented

@TobiPeterG Sounds like a different issue to the one here - maybe create a different report?

commented

@TobiPeterG Sounds like a different issue to the one here - maybe create a different report?

Yeah, ofc, just wanted to hear if someone can confirm that issue before I open a new thread and nobody has that issue. :D

commented

@TobiPeterG Sounds like a different issue to the one here - maybe create a different report?

Yeah, ofc, just wanted to hear if someone can confirm that issue before I open a new thread and nobody has that issue. :D

Sure, its just that this issue is about crashes with the xbox one controller, and your issue is completely different...

commented

Anyway, I'm installing openSUSE Tumbleweed today in fact. So I'll see if my issue is then resolved. I need to find a way to check if the kernel-provided xbox driver is loaded though.

commented

@TobiPeterG Sounds like a different issue to the one here - maybe create a different report?

Yeah, ofc, just wanted to hear if someone can confirm that issue before I open a new thread and nobody has that issue. :D

Sure, its just that this issue is about crashes with the xbox one controller, and your issue is completely different...

Yeah, I know. It's just that there's a chance that none of you would have seen that new issue and there're not soo many people using Linux for Minecraft gaming, so I thought, maybe one of you had the same problem and could confirm it or had the same issue and know a fix I just didn't think of.
And a whole bug report for "you have to do "... "" to fix it would have been unnecessary.

Ofc, creating a bug report for that would have been the correct way and if nobody else comments that he had that issue / knows how to fix it in the next few hours, I'll create a report, don't worry. ;)
Didn't want to bother you, sorry.

commented

Anyway, I'm installing openSUSE Tumbleweed today in fact. So I'll see if my issue is then resolved. I need to find a way to check if the kernel-provided xbox driver is loaded though.

Oh OK, thank you. It might be important to say that I'm using KDE, that may be related to the issue I had.
Don't know though what you're planning to install.

commented

@TobiPeterG Sounds like a different issue to the one here - maybe create a different report?

Yeah, ofc, just wanted to hear if someone can confirm that issue before I open a new thread and nobody has that issue. :D

Sure, its just that this issue is about crashes with the xbox one controller, and your issue is completely different...

Yeah, I know. It's just that there's a chance that none of you would have seen that new issue and there're not soo many people using Linux for Minecraft gaming, so I thought, maybe one of you had the same problem and could confirm it or had the same issue and know a fix I just didn't think of.
And a whole bug report for "you have to do "... "" to fix it would have been unnecessary.

Ofc, creating a bug report for that would have been the correct way and if nobody else comments that he had that issue / knows how to fix it in the next few hours, I'll create a report, don't worry. ;)
Didn't want to bother you, sorry.

Don't worry about it ๐Ÿ˜„

commented

Anyway, I'm installing openSUSE Tumbleweed today in fact. So I'll see if my issue is then resolved. I need to find a way to check if the kernel-provided xbox driver is loaded though.

Oh OK, thank you. It might be important to say that I'm using KDE, that may be related to the issue I had.
Don't know though what you're planning to install.

I was on Arch, but I miss zypper. Also, I moved to Arch to try and fix an issue I had with my USB-C dock and the kernel (newer version), but think I've found the bug..

commented

Anyway, I'm installing openSUSE Tumbleweed today in fact. So I'll see if my issue is then resolved. I need to find a way to check if the kernel-provided xbox driver is loaded though.

Oh OK, thank you. It might be important to say that I'm using KDE, that may be related to the issue I had.
Don't know though what you're planning to install.

I was on Arch, but I miss zypper. Also, I moved to Arch to try and fix an issue I had with my USB-C dock and the kernel (newer version), but think I've found the bug..

Is the kernel on Arch really that much newer? O.o
Afaik the newest version is 5.6-16 I think and Tumbleweed has 5.6-12 when I remember correctly.
However, the important thing is that you found the bug. ;)

Ps: zypper's great, but I'd like to have a build in option to search the obs. :D