Croptopia

Croptopia

30M Downloads

single seed crops give a second seed when harvested with right click

RoseWarbug1 opened this issue ยท 2 comments

commented

Make sure you are not opening a duplicate.

Platform.

Forge

Minecraft version.

1.19.2

Croptopia version.

2.2.2

What happened?

I was using mystical agriculture mod with this, the seeds such as diamond seeds, or nether star seeds, when harvested with right click function from croptopia, it re-plants it and gives an extra seed, which breaks balance, and allows easy access to a valuable resource. so I thought that was not intentional, and wanted to somehow report it, if there is anything that can be done about crops that give a single seed when harvested.

2023-01-30_09 35 32
2 crops in the same condition, from mystical agriculture

2023-01-30_09 35 43
when I harvest the one on the left the default way, breaking, it gives me one seed and one resource.

2023-01-30_09 35 54
when I harvest the one on the right using croptopias right click harvest, it re-plants it, AND gives me another seed, while this crop is not supposed to give me more than one seed, and this seems unintended as it is an exploit that can give an advantage compared to not using it. so I wanted to write about it here

Relevant log.

No response

Additional information.

only mods involved are:
-mystical agriculture 1.19.2 6.0.5
-croptopia 1.19.2 FORGE 2.2.2

commented

didn't respond for a long time, but I think I've decided this is out of scope for croptopia to change. I'd recommend disabling croptopia's right click harvest and using another RCH mod, or changing the loot table for mystical agriculture to not ever always drop a seed

commented

I'd really think you should consider writing in an exception for mystag, or at least give the option to blacklist certain mods from the right click harvest. Getting seeds for free like this in mystag really ruins the balance and progression