Double Hotbar

Double Hotbar

32.7k Downloads

Request for a single 18 slot hotbar (and tricks to emulate it)

GrenFlem opened this issue · 6 comments

commented

The ability to automatically swap to the hotbar just by scrolling off the edge of the main one without swapping positions of them, effectively making the hotbar 18 slots

commented

Yes, please! I was about to say the same thing, I don't want a new keybind or the need to press it all the time, I wish to just scroll through all the slots normally.
Also add a configurable option for displaying the two hotbars side by side smoothly as one 18-slots long hotbar rather than two on top of one another.

commented

There used to be a mod named "Extended Hotbar" that did this. I used that mod up until Minecraft 1.21 was released, when it did not update to support the new version. I then used the unofficial pull until 1.21.2+ (iirc), when that pull also stopped working.

commented

This is a client side mod intended to be usable on vanilla servers. That means it has to obey the server and the vanilla server does not allow the placement or use of any items/blocks not on the normal hotbar. This means there has to be a swap. Additionally, adding more features and injections into the game code increases the maintenance overhead of the mod for me and causes more crashes, bugs, and issues for all users. Adding the features requested in this issue would nearly double the codebase of the mod. I am aware of the other mods that have existed in the same area, but if this mod is to stay up to date and functional then I have to limit its size.

In addition to the technical reasons, there are also design choices I made that I think make for a clear, easy to learn, and quick to master solution for using 18 slots. In early development I tested an “auto swap on scroll off the edge” function. It was clunky, confusing, and unappealing to me. My suggestion is to make more use of the “hold to swap a single stack” function or experiment with the option that flips the hotkey so you hold to swap the whole bar and tap to swap a single stack.

My apologies for the disappointing news, but I do appreciate the suggestions.