Emendatus Enigmatica

Emendatus Enigmatica

3M Downloads

EE's Silicon cannot replace RS's Silicon

ilhamfu opened this issue · 7 comments

commented

Mod Version
EmendatusEnigmatica-1.16.5-1.2.9
refinedstorage-1.9.15

Describe the bug/enhancement
It seems EE silicon recipes overlap with the RS Silicon but can't replace it in the RS recipe

commented

Are you playing a specific modpack, or are you making your own?

commented

making my own, my current solution is disabling the recipe with craft tweaker but I hope EE can fix this issue

commented

I guess in theory I can add refinedstorage:silicon tag to EE Silicon, but that goes against the concept of unification with tags. I'll reach out to RS Devs, and see whether they would be willing to switch to forge:silicon instead, especially that it is already reading for a tag.
Example: https://github.com/refinedmods/refinedstorage/blob/mc1.16/src/main/resources/data/refinedstorage/recipes/raw_basic_processor.json

commented

At a quick glance, this is due to RS not using Tags for the Silicon input, and therefore the only 2 options are:

  • Replace the recipes that require silicon to accept anything with forge:silicon
  • Disable EE recipe for Silicon

The above can be easily achieved with KubeJS/Craft Tweaker

I will review it further later on tonight, and see if I can do something from my side, but I doubt it. Will update this item with my finding.

commented

thanks for looking up this issue, I was just about to reach out to RS Devs and AE2 Devs about this, cus both of them add silicon and didn't use a unifying tag which causes lots of unnecessary issues. maybe adding config to disable silicon can resolve this issue on the EE side

commented

This will be fixed in a future release when I release EE V2.0 which will be completely data driven registries, so modpack devs can add and remove any item they want. Until then, I would recommend either of the 2 solutions above.

commented