Before Continuing:

• Always check you are using the latest version of the mods and its dependencies
• Remove mod that enhances Minecraft: Optifine, Sodium, others. The issue still persists.
• If you are unsure which mod is the culprit.
  Disable all of your mods and enable them 1-2 mods each time to isolate the culprit
• Confirm that there is no existing issue with a similar description submitted in the list of issues.

Version

1.20.1

Loader

Forge

EveryCompat Version

everycomp-1.20-2.6.18

Moonlight Lib Version

moonlight-1.20-2.8.67

Issue with mods

Chipped-1.20.1-3.0.1
Woodster-1.4.5

Issue Detail

Chipped adds several bookshelf variants to the base (oak) bookshelves. Every Compact does not yet extend them to bookshelf wood types added by Woodster .

OPTIONAL: Latest.log | Crash-report Attachment

No response

OPTIONAL: To Produce

No response

Can you check to see if Woodster's Wood Type has the sound "Bass"?

Wait a min, IIRC woodster doesn't have any wood types

Chipped adds variants for Oak Bookshelves, the only bookshelf type present in vanilla.
It does not add these variants for other wood types.

Woodster adds bookshelves for All Vanilla Wood Types. Every Compact extends this to any new wood types.

The suggestion is to add chipped bookshelf variants to all loaded wood types when Woodster is also loaded.

Ah, I understand the problem. Thanks for the clarification. Hmm, when since did Chipped add new blocks, "Bookshelf".

EDIT:
I see what's going on. The reason why Bookshelf wasn't added is because Chipped only has one wood type: Oak for Bookshelf. that's it.

Woodster Module supported Chiseled Bookshelf & Bookshelf and it should be loaded with wood types from any mods. Thanks to your report (not related), I found some problems with the module and applied some fixes,

EDIT 2:
I forgot to mention. there are 33 types of Bookshelf and if it's added. It could lead to Minecraft exploding (in other words, crashing due to not enough RAM or whatever)

Woodster adds bookshelves for all wood types. chipped bookshelf variations are not generated for these new shelves.

Woodster adds bookshelves for all wood types. chipped bookshelf variations are not generated for these new shelves.

[ Deleted ]

EDIT:

Ok, i am confused. Can you clarify what you said.

From what I understand is that
Woodster have:

• Bookshelf
• Chiseled Bookshelf
• no wood types.

Chipped have:

• Types of planks,
• Others.
• no wood types.

Every Compat is not designed to combine the blocks between Woodster & Chipped because they don't have Wood types. It's designed to combine a block (Furniture or block) from one mod with Wood Types from mods like Biomes O' Plenty

I'm not sure

@MehVahdJukaar
is it fine to add Bookshelf (33 types) to module. If it's too much, one could disable it from being added via Every Compat (EC)'s Config? or Nah?
I wasn't able to decide whether should i close this issue or add the 33 types of bookshelf to EC

UPDATE:

Well, the decision is to not add 33 types of Bookshelf to EveryCompat. 3 reasons:

1. 33 x 6 woodTypes from a wood mods = 198 blocks. The more woodTypes, the greater the number will be.
2. I added stripped_log and log (they each 9-11 blocks) which is okay-ish.
3. if 33 bookshelf can be reduced to one block using 33 different textures. This is possible in other mods. You could let the author know about it. if he change it to 1 bookshelf with 33 different textures using a Carpenter's Table.

then I can add it to EveryCompat. and if he could do same with other blocks. and then I can add all of them to EveryComp. It could reduce the resources by adding 1 block with 33 different textures compared to add blocks to Minecraft.

The amount of blocks added by Chipped & EveryComp is quite high depending on wood mods. That's all.