[Feature Request] Sieve Recipes do not interact well with EMI
Closed this issue · 5 comments
Is there an existing issue for this?
- I have searched the existing issues
Current Behavior
If a recipe tree is created using EMI for a recipe involving a sieving process:
- Each recipe batch is including the mesh as an ingredient requirement for the recipe, even when meshes are non-consumable
- Percent changes are ignored when determining outputs
Expected Behavior
- When meshes are non-consumable, only one mesh should be required regardless of batch multiple. See image below for an equivalent working example via GregTechCEu Modern and its Plate Mold:
- If an item has a % drop chance from a recipe, then the quantity should be based on the average % per individual recipe batch. See image below for an equivalent working example via GregTechCEu Modern and its Sticky Resin Recipe (50% chance / Rubber Log):
Steps to Reproduce
N/A
Minecraft Version
1.20.X
Forge Version
47.4.0
Ex Nihilo: Sequentia Version
5.0.0
Additional Context
Tested using EMI v1.1.22 for 1.20.1 inside the Star Technology modpack (latest as of 2025-05-06). JEI is also installed at v15.20.0.106.
Log File
Since EXN was never built with EMI compatibility, this is not surprising. This isn't really a bug, but more a feature request.
Hey again, one other compat issue that I also found: Recipes related to melting are viewed as "one of every" rather than an oredict/tag wildcard, and the fluid quantity that gets created is also ignored.
E.g. here with saplings turning into water via a barrel:
As Nova already mentioned, Ex Nihilo Sequentia doesn't have native EMI support. Today I released some support for EMI with my addon Ex Nihilo: Additions for 1.20.1. The only issue I have right now is: If you have JEI installed you'll see both, ExNihiloSequentia's recipes and my EMI implementation. I'm still trying to disable the JEI compat inside the base mod itself but that'll take another week. If you don't need JEI you can disable the mod itself so you only see the addon version.
As Nova already mentioned, Ex Nihilo Sequentia doesn't have native EMI support. Today I released some support for EMI with my addon Ex Nihilo: Additions for 1.20.1. The only issue I have right now is: If you have JEI installed you'll see both, ExNihiloSequentia's recipes and my EMI implementation. I'm still trying to disable the JEI compat inside the base mod itself but that'll take another week. If you don't need JEI you can disable the mod itself so you only see the addon version.
Yeah I'm aware now about that, I just wanted to mention this since it was different from the contents in the OP. Thanks for looking into compat though!