Farmers delight mostly does foods that are eaten from a bowl or plate that are warm like soups and stews will have comforting. (That is, if they aren't overly complex enough to be nourishing since nourishing is stronger comfort basically)

While those which are large meals or served from feasts are usually cooked in pots with having nourishing from 1-5 mins depending on the complexity and steps required to make... like that chefs salad etc.

Can you audit your foods at some point and sprinkle around the buffs? More fulfilling and rewarding that way.

Additionally for bonus points: consider adding the tag "salt:can_be_salted" since there is a mod called "the salt" which allows you to season foods with salt from the mod to make foods slightly more nourishing also dynamically. all you need to do is tag the finished and foods which would be nice with a bit o seasoning. :)

got any specifics? I thought i was pretty generous with the comfort/nourishment effects

yes.

As far as I could tell, a lot of your feast based meals would need nourishing of some level, while all your soups could use comfort. I'll go through them. give me a bit and I'll make a table or something...

oh. weird, why do your foods not display they're nourishing when they are? I just noticed it. they don't have tooltips like farmers delight things do, thats why I automatically assumed they didn't have.

Are you able to patch that? cause I was very confused at the lack of nourishment and comfort all over things when you said you were very generous with them.

meanwhile:

farmers delight stuff and even some vanilla stuff it edits actually has it showing properly.

I would imagine it needs to be done manually with a tooltip added to the item of your own design/taken from farmers delight which does them. similar to the colored tooltips you have on your 4 juices, but displaying the buff durations. even if 3 of them have broken localization.