FallingTree

FallingTree

28M Downloads

Mangrove roots arent breaking

JamieTheNeko opened this issue ยท 9 comments

commented

Describe the bug

I have the setting for mangrove roots on, but they wont break at all. i have to go fishing for the wood
2022-07-13_17 37 24
2022-07-13_17 37 29
2022-07-13_17 37 06
.

Minecraft version

1.19

Fabric API version

0.55.3

Mod version

3.6.1

Relevant log output

No response

commented

My "fix" was if you wanted to break the whole tree by breaking a root.
But seems like you bread the trunk. Can you share your config file?

Yeah I wanted to break the whole tree from the trunk. I tried the fix but it only broke the roots and not the trunk. Then I tried it on the allowed leaves too. I'll have to share it a bit later as my power is out

I just found a fix. But that might be an issue for you too. It's linked to the nether warts. As soon as I switched it on. It instantly broke the whole tree

But still some roots don't break always but I can get that, that's just how it works.

commented

I just found a fix. But that might be an issue for you too. It's linked to the nether warts. As soon as I switched it on. It instantly broke the whole tree

So:

  • if you have "Break nether warts" off + "Break mangrove roots" on => Does not break the roots
  • if you have "Break nether warts" on + "Break mangrove roots" on => Does break the roots

Correct?

Edit: Ok I manage to reproduce it that way ๐Ÿ‘

commented

Good find, I was basically "tagging" the roots as warts when scanning the tree ๐Ÿ˜…

Will make a release in a bit.

commented

So if I understand well you're breaking the roots and you expect the whole tree to fall?

If so then this is normal behavior, the roots are considered "leaves" so they are breaking when the associated trunk is destroyed. So that indeed mean you have to reach for it.

If you want to have the root act like it's the trunk you can :

  • Add "minecraft:mangrove_roots" to be allowed logs
  • Enable "Allow trunks with mixed logs"
commented

If you mean that you break the trunk and nothing else disappears, then I can't manage to reproduce it.
Tried with FT 3.7.2 & Fabric 0.56.0+1.19. Can you reproduce with those latest versions?

commented

If you mean that you break the trunk and nothing else disappears, then I can't manage to reproduce it. Tried with FT 3.7.2 & Fabric 0.56.0+1.19. Can you reproduce with those latest versions?

i did update it all.. still no change.. the roots dont break with the tree. the leaves do but the roots dont. i will try your fix and let you know

commented

My "fix" was if you wanted to break the whole tree by breaking a root.

But seems like you bread the trunk.
Can you share your config file?

commented

My "fix" was if you wanted to break the whole tree by breaking a root.
But seems like you bread the trunk. Can you share your config file?

Yeah I wanted to break the whole tree from the trunk. I tried the fix but it only broke the roots and not the trunk. Then I tried it on the allowed leaves too. I'll have to share it a bit later as my power is out

I just found a fix. But that might be an issue for you too. It's linked to the nether warts. As soon as I switched it on. It instantly broke the whole tree

commented

My "fix" was if you wanted to break the whole tree by breaking a root.

But seems like you bread the trunk. Can you share your config file?

Yeah I wanted to break the whole tree from the trunk. I tried the fix but it only broke the roots and not the trunk. Then I tried it on the allowed leaves too. I'll have to share it a bit later as my power is out