FancyMenu [Fabric] [MOVED TO NEW PROJECT]

FancyMenu [Fabric] [MOVED TO NEW PROJECT]

16M Downloads

Incompatibility with "Remove Reloading Screen" in MC versions before 1.20.4

Jadan1213 opened this issue ยท 13 comments

commented

Describe the bug
When using the mod "remove reloading screen" which reloads resources in the background without being stuck on a reloading screen, if you go to the main menu, Fancy menu crashes. If you wait for the resource reload to complete before going back to the main title screen, there is no crash.

Game Log
https://gist.github.com/Jadan1213/f9ff4cd6558f0d7a87c47d83d37138b1

Basic Informations (please complete the following information):

  • OS: Windows 10
  • FancyMenu Version: 3.1.2
  • Forge/Fabric Version : Forge 47.2.17
  • Minecraft Version: 1.20.1
  • Active Mods: a lot....
commented

Try to remove Seamless Loading Screen.

commented

Try to remove Seamless Loading Screen.

seamless loading screen would have nothing to do with it, that just shows a screenshot of the last place you logged out while loading in, and fades into the world. (i disabled just to test, and it still crashed).

I'll save us some troubleshooting time. Made a barebones instance and the crash still happened.

latest.log: https://gist.github.com/Jadan1213/c85d1bbcc525f5e0b3987d8bf1baa1a0
Crash log: https://gist.github.com/Jadan1213/db455bcca2efe6df4876d5d8503cf886
Debug log: https://gist.github.com/Jadan1213/d8ce697ef161637933bf99de696f5088

commented

I just noticed your thread that you opened regarding incompatibility. I also use Not enough crashes, so it's not a game breaking thing when it happens. I just click back to title, or if i'm not loaded into a world, i just wait for the resources to finish reloading before clicking back to title so it doesn't crash. But hopefully my logs could be helpful.

commented

The crash is probably caused by Remove Reloading Screen, because I tried to fix an incompatibility with it in the past but exactly this "fix" seems to crash the game now because something in RRLS changed probably.

[23Mar2024 05:36:50.275] [main/INFO] [Puzzles Lib/]: Loading 36 mods:
	- badpackets 0.4.3
	- balm 7.2.2
	- clienttweaks 11.1.0
	- cloth_config 11.1.118
	- craftingtweaks 18.2.3
	- dimensionteleport 2.0.1
	- easyshulkerboxes 8.0.2
	- embeddium 0.3.9+mc1.20.1
	- embeddiumplus 1.2.5
	- emi 1.1.3+1.20.1+forge
	- emi_loot 0.6.5+1.20.1+forge
	- emiffect 1.1.2+mc1.20.1
	- emitrades 1.2.1+mc1.20.1
	- entityculling 1.6.2
	- fancymenu 3.1.2
	- ferritecore 6.0.1
	- forge 47.2.17
	- immediatelyfast 1.2.10+1.20.4
	- jade 11.8.0
	- jei 15.3.0.4
	- konkrete 1.8.0
	- melody 1.0.2
	- memoryleakfix 1.1.5
	- minecraft 1.20.1
	- mixinextras 0.3.5
	- modernfix 5.14.0+mc1.20.1
	- mousetweaks 2.25
	- puzzlesaccessapi 8.0.9
	- puzzlesapi 8.1.6
	- puzzleslib 8.1.18
	- reeses_sodium_options 1.0.4
	- rrls 3.2.0-1.20.1-forge <----------------------------------------
	- rubidium 0.7.1
	- smoothboot 0.0.4
	- starlight 1.1.2+forge.1cda73c
	- textrues_embeddium_options 0.1.5+mc1.20.1
commented

Oh nvm, this is a duplicate of #729.
Will keep this one open and close the other one instead, because this one has better logs, etc.

commented

Oh nvm, this is a duplicate of #729. Will keep this one open and close the other one instead, because this one has better logs, etc.

alright, if you need anyone to test any fixes, i'd be happy to try and help.

commented

The crash is probably caused by Remove Reloading Screen, because I tried to fix an incompatibility with it in the past but exactly this "fix" seems to crash the game now because something in RRLS changed probably.

[23Mar2024 05:36:50.275] [main/INFO] [Puzzles Lib/]: Loading 36 mods:
	- badpackets 0.4.3
	- balm 7.2.2
	- clienttweaks 11.1.0
	- cloth_config 11.1.118
	- craftingtweaks 18.2.3
	- dimensionteleport 2.0.1
	- easyshulkerboxes 8.0.2
	- embeddium 0.3.9+mc1.20.1
	- embeddiumplus 1.2.5
	- emi 1.1.3+1.20.1+forge
	- emi_loot 0.6.5+1.20.1+forge
	- emiffect 1.1.2+mc1.20.1
	- emitrades 1.2.1+mc1.20.1
	- entityculling 1.6.2
	- fancymenu 3.1.2
	- ferritecore 6.0.1
	- forge 47.2.17
	- immediatelyfast 1.2.10+1.20.4
	- jade 11.8.0
	- jei 15.3.0.4
	- konkrete 1.8.0
	- melody 1.0.2
	- memoryleakfix 1.1.5
	- minecraft 1.20.1
	- mixinextras 0.3.5
	- modernfix 5.14.0+mc1.20.1
	- mousetweaks 2.25
	- puzzlesaccessapi 8.0.9
	- puzzlesapi 8.1.6
	- puzzleslib 8.1.18
	- reeses_sodium_options 1.0.4
	- rrls 3.2.0-1.20.1-forge <----------------------------------------
	- rubidium 0.7.1
	- smoothboot 0.0.4
	- starlight 1.1.2+forge.1cda73c
	- textrues_embeddium_options 0.1.5+mc1.20.1

To respond to your comment you seem to have edited
image

compared to my 500+ modpack that i run, yes, this is barebones. It's a small selection of performance mods and client tweak mods that i use to test when other mods crash. this lets me test without having 500 mods loaded. It's easy to disable a few mods in a small pack to test an incompatability, it's not so easy with 500 of them.

commented

Uhm that's not what I said, please read the message again :D
I updated the comment a bit now, to make it more clear :)

commented

Update

The upcoming FancyMenu update will make "Remove Reloading Screen" fully INcompatible with FancyMenu on MC versions before 1.20.4! The game will not start anymore if both RRLS and FM are installed at the same time in MC versions before 1.20.4.

Both mods work fine together in MC 1.20.4+, so I will only remove my old compatibility fix on these versions, because it is not needed anymore. The game continues to start without issues in MC 1.20.4+.

commented

I appreciate you backporting the fix!!

commented

Oh, well damn lol. I must have missed that when I read it.

commented

I guess it's a good thing I removed the remove reloading screen mod already lol

commented

Fixed/Added in FancyMenu v3.1.3!