Farmer's Delight

Farmer's Delight

77M Downloads

[Farmers Delight MC 1.16.5] Villagers do not harvest on Rich Soil

TheSwitzVirgin opened this issue · 3 comments

commented

I recently swapped the vanilla dirt farmland with the rich soil farmland of the mod and I only planted there the vanilla crops, like potatoes and carrots. After the crops were ready to be harvested the Villagers don't harvest them.

Steps to reproduce:
Changed Dirt Farmland with the Rich Soil Farmland and planted with vanilla crops. But the Villagers don't harvest the crops.

Expected behavior:
The Villagers harvesting the vanilla crops from the Rich Soil farmland.

Mod list:
Camels-1.16.5-1.0.0.jar |Camels Mod |camels |1.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
blue_skies-1.16.5-1.1.3.jar |Blue Skies |blue_skies |1.1.3 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
supermartijn642configlib-1.0.4-mc1.16.jar |SuperMartijn642's Config Lib |supermartijn642configlib |1.0.4 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
blood-particles-1.16.3-1.0.1.jar |Blood Particles |blood_particles |1.0.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
potiondescriptions-1.16.3-1.4.0.jar |Potion Descriptions |potiondescriptions |1.16.3-1.4.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
infernal-expansion-forge-1.3.jar |Infernal Expansion |infernalexp |Release 1.3 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
TRansliterationLib-1.0.1.jar |TRansliterationLib Mod |transliterationlib |1.0.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
jei-1.16.4-7.6.1.66.jar |Just Enough Items |jei |7.6.1.66 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
DoggyTalents-1.16.5-2.1.0.0.jar |Doggy Talents 2 |doggytalents |2.1.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
mcw-windows-1.0.3-mc1.16.5.jar |Macaw's Windows |mcwwindows |1.0.3 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
caelus-forge-1.16.5-2.1.3.0.jar |Caelus API |caelus |1.16.5-2.1.3.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
Kobolds-1.5.1.jar |Kobolds |kobolds |1.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
farsight-1.4.2-1.16.5.jar |Farsight |farsight_spyglasses |1.4.2-1.16.5 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
ForgeEndertech-1.16.4-7.0.10.0-build.0037.jar |Forge Endertech |forgeendertech |7.0.10.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
BetterPortals-1.16.4-0.3.2.jar |YUNG's Better Portals |betterportals |1.16.4-0.3.2 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
villagernames_1.16.5-3.3.jar |Villager Names |villagernames |3.3 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
TerraForged-1.16.4-0.2.3.jar |TerraForged |terraforged |0.2.3 |DONE |7b:73:d0:a2:c3:40:13:84:35:4f:c9:0e:2b:85:8c:08:ea:3c:3c:eb:f1:98:8b:5b:6e:ca:8a:a0:9a:cf:12:b3
mcw-paintings-1.0.0-mc1.16.4-5.jar |Macaw's Paintings |mcwpaintings |1.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
journeymap-1.16.5-5.7.1b4.jar |Journeymap |journeymap |5.7.1b4 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
citadel-1.8.1-1.16.5.jar |Citadel |citadel |1.8.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
alexsmobs-1.12.0.jar |Alex's Mobs |alexsmobs |1.12.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
TravelersBackpack-1.16.5-5.4.2.jar |Traveler's Backpack |travelersbackpack |5.4.2 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
YungsApi-1.16.4-Forge-4.jar |YUNG's API |yungsapi |1.16.4-Forge-4 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
netheritehorsearmor-1.7.jar |Netherite Horse Armor Mod |netheritehorsearmor |1.7 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
Multiplayer-Server-Pause-1.16.5-Forge-1.0.0.jar |Multiplayer Server Pause |serverpause |1.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
curioofundying-forge-1.16.4-5.1.0.0.jar |Curio of Undying |curioofundying |1.16.4-5.1.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
MutantBeasts-1.16.4-1.1.3.jar |Mutant Beasts |mutantbeasts |1.16.4-1.1.3 |DONE |d9:be:bd:b6:9a:e4:14:aa:05:67:fb:84:06:77:a0:c5:10:ec:27:15:1b:d6:c0:88:49:9a:ef:26:77:61:0b:5e
Bookshelf-1.16.5-10.0.1.jar |Bookshelf |bookshelf |10.0.1 |DONE |eb:c4:b1:67:8b:f9:0c:db:dc:4f:01:b1:8e:61:64:39:4c:10:85:0b:a6:c4:c7:48:f0:fa:95:f2:cb:08:3a:e5
guardvillagers-1.16.5.1.2.6.jar |Guard Villagers |guardvillagers |1.2.6 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
mcw-doors-1.0.2-mc1.16.5.jar |Macaw's Doors |mcwdoors |1.0.2 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
iceandfire-2.1.9-1.16.5.jar |Ice and Fire |iceandfire |2.1.9-1.16.5 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
carryon-1.16.5-1.15.5.15.jar |Carry On |carryon |1.15.5.15 |DONE |8c:03:ac:7d:21:62:65:e2:83:91:f3:22:57:99:ed:75:78:1e:db:de:03:99:ef:53:3b:59:95:18:01:bc:84:a9
Wandering-Bag-1.16.5-1.0.2.jar |Wandering Bag |wandering_bag |1.0.2 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
forge-1.16.5-36.1.23-universal.jar |Forge |forge |36.1.23 |DONE |22:af:21:d8:19:82:7f:93:94:fe:2b:ac:b7:e4:41:57:68:39:87:b1:a7:5c:c6:44:f9:25:74:21:14:f5:0d:90
shetiphiancore-1.16-3.8.5.jar |ShetiPhian-Core |shetiphiancore |3.8.5 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
MoreCraftingTables+-+1.16.5.jar |More Crafting Tables Mod |mctb |1.16.5 - 1.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
MmmMmmMmmMmm-1.16-1.0.1.jar |MmmMmmMmmMmm |dummmmmmy |1.0.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
twilightforest-1.16.5-4.0.546-universal.jar |The Twilight Forest |twilightforest |NONE |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
tl_skin_cape_forge_1.16.5-1.19.jar |TLSkinCape |tlskincape |1.19 |DONE |19:f5:ce:44:81:0c:e4:22:05:5e:73:c5:a8:cd:de:f3:c8:cf:a9:b3:01:70:40:a0:ee:2d:50:7a:1c:3d:1c:8a
supplementaries-1.16.5-0.16.1.jar |Supplementaries |supplementaries |1.16.5-0.16.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
betterendforge-1.16.4-1.4.1.jar |BetterEnd Forge |betterendforge |1.16.4-1.4.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
DynamicSurroundings-1.16.4-4.0.3.8.jar |Dynamic Surroundings |dsurround |1.16.4-4.0.3.8 |DONE |b4:98:14:b9:76:55:25:4f:e5:5f:4d:71:90:87:43:5b:f9:d5:3a:02:60:42:5e:da:1f:15:9c:ff:be:a9:7c:77
structure_gel-1.16.5-1.7.8.jar |Structure Gel API |structure_gel |1.7.8 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
selene-1.16.5-1.7.jar |Selene |selene |1.16.5-1.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
corpse-1.16.5-1.0.0.jar |Corpse |corpse |1.16.5-1.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
forge-1.16.5-36.1.23-client.jar |Minecraft |minecraft |1.16.5 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
FarmersDelight-1.16.5-0.4.2.jar |Farmer's Delight |farmersdelight |1.16.5-0.4.2 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
customizableelytra-1.16.4-1.4.3.jar |Customizable Elytra |customizableelytra |1.16.4-1.4.3 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
morevillagers-FORGE-1.16.5-1.5.4.jar |More Villagers |morevillagers |1.5.4 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
EnchantmentDescriptions-1.16.5-7.0.8.jar |EnchantmentDescriptions |enchdesc |7.0.8 |DONE |eb:c4:b1:67:8b:f9:0c:db:dc:4f:01:b1:8e:61:64:39:4c:10:85:0b:a6:c4:c7:48:f0:fa:95:f2:cb:08:3a:e5
[1.16.5]Gender-1.7.5.jar |Gender |gender |1.7.5 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
BiomesOPlenty-1.16.5-13.1.0.459-universal.jar |Biomes O' Plenty |biomesoplenty |1.16.4-13.0.0.439 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
EndRemastered-R352.jar |End Remastered 3.5.2 |endrem |1.16.3 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
SaveYourPets-1.16.2-1.0.0.5.jar |Save Your Pets |syp |1.0.0.5 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
CreativeCore_v2.0.10_mc1.16.4.jar |CreativeCore |creativecore |2.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
mcw-trapdors-1.0.1-mc1.16.5.jar |Macaw's Trapdoors |mcwtrpdoors |1.0.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
mcw-fences-1.0.0-mc1.16.5.jar |Macaw's Fences and Walls |mcwfences |1.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
AdLods-1.16.4-4.1.3.0-build.0034.jar |Large Ore Deposits |adlods |4.1.3.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
astikorcarts-1.16.4-1.1.0.jar |AstikorCarts |astikorcarts |1.1.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
Bountiful-1.16.4-3.3.0.jar |Bountiful |bountiful |1.16.4-3.3.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
majrusz-library-1.16.4-2.0.1.jar |Majrusz Library |majrusz_library |2.0.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
notenoughanimations-1.1.0.jar |NotEnoughAnimations Mod |notenoughanimations |1.1.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
SpartanShields-1.16.4-2.1.1.jar |Spartan Shields |spartanshields |2.1.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
Patchouli-1.16.4-50.jar |Patchouli |patchouli |1.16.4-50 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
diet-forge-1.16.5-0.30.jar |Diet |diet |1.16.5-0.30 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
collective-1.16.5-2.64.jar |Collective |collective |2.64 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
multibeds-1.16-1.7.8.jar |Multi-Beds |multibeds |1.7.8 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
ToughAsNails-1.16.5-4.0.1.23-universal.jar |Tough As Nails |toughasnails |1.16.5-4.0.1.15 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
survivaloverhaul-1.16.5-0.4.1b.jar |Survival Overhaul |survivaloverhaul |1.16.5-0.4.1b |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
SereneSeasons-1.16.5-4.0.1.91-universal.jar |Serene Seasons |sereneseasons |1.16.5-4.0.1.91 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
curios-forge-1.16.5-4.0.5.3.jar |Curios API |curios |1.16.5-4.0.5.3 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
eidolon-0.2.7.jar |Eidolon |eidolon |0.2.7 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
illagersweararmor-1.0.4.jar |Illagers Wear Armor |illagersweararmor |1.0.4 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
TinyChests-1.4.2.jar |Tiny Chests |tinychest |1.4.2 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
majruszs-difficulty-1.16.4-1.1.0.jar |Majrusz's Progressive Difficul|majruszs_difficulty |1.1.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
majruszsaccessories-1.16.5-0.1.4.jar |Majrusz's Accessories |majruszs_accessories |0.1.4 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
SpartanWeaponry-1.16.4-2.1.0-beta-4.jar |Spartan Weaponry |spartanweaponry |2.1.0 beta 4 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
SolarHelmet-1.1.0.jar |SolarHelmet |solarhelmet |1.1.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
curiouselytra-forge-1.16.5-4.0.2.0.jar |Curious Elytra |curiouselytra |1.16.5-4.0.2.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
mcw-furniture-2.0.1-mc1.16.5.jar |Macaw's Furniture |mcwfurnitures |2.0.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
globalxp-1.16.5-v1.8.jar |Global XP |globalxp |v1.8 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
The_Undergarden-1.16.5-0.5.2.jar |The Undergarden |undergarden |0.5.2 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
chunkloaders-1.1.6-mc1.16.5.jar |Chunk Loaders |chunkloaders |1.1.6 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
Aquaculture-1.16.5-2.1.21.jar |Aquaculture 2 |aquaculture |1.16.5-2.1.21 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
AdChimneys-1.16.4-6.0.6.0-build.0037.jar |Advanced Chimneys |adchimneys |6.0.6.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
illagers_plus-1.16.4v1.7.2.jar |Illagers+ |illagers_plus |1.16.4v1.7.2 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
FallingTree-Forge-1.16.5-2.10.2.jar |Falling Tree |fallingtree |2.10.2 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
smallships-1.16.5-1.10.1.jar |Small Ships Mod |smallships |1.10.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
valhelsia_core-16.0.9.jar |Valhelsia Core |valhelsia_core |16.0.9 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
valhelsia_structures-1.16.5-0.1.2.jar |Valhelsia Structures |valhelsia_structures |1.16.5-0.1.2 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
overloadedarmorbar-5.1.0.jar |Overloaded Armor Bar |overloadedarmorbar |5.1.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
chiselsandbits-0.2.10-RELEASE.jar |Chisels & bits |chiselsandbits |NONE |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
BetterMineshafts-Forge-1.16.4-2.0.1.jar |YUNG's Better Mineshafts |bettermineshafts |1.16.4-2.0.1 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
NekosEnchantedBooks-1.16-1.0.0.jar |NekoпїЅs Enchanted Books |nebs |1.0.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
EnderMail-1.16.5-1.2.0.jar |Ender Mail |endermail |1.16.5-1.2.0 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE
farlanders-1.16.4-1.3.9.jar |The Farlanders |farlanders |1.3.9 |DONE |NOSIGNATURE

commented

This is a known limitation with vanilla code. Villagers are hard-coded to look specifically for normal Farmland and nothing else; similarly, they only consider vanilla crops "replantable", despite being able to break modded ones.

Tweaking this from FD's end takes quite a bit of code, and I couldn't get around to planning this yet, but the issue is known.

As a workaround for now, I recommend checking this mod out, by the creator of Supplementaries:
https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/smarter-farmers-farmers-replant

commented

Thanks for the fast answer, I checked it now with the mod "Smarter Farmers", but they still don't plant on the Rich Soil farmland. Thank you for the help anyway 👍

commented

Thanks for the fast answer, I checked it now with the mod "Smarter Farmers", but they still don't plant on the Rich Soil farmland. Thank you for the help anyway 👍谢谢你的快速回答,我现在用国防部“聪明的农民”检查了一下,但是他们仍然不种植在肥沃的土地上。谢谢你的帮助,无论如何。

If you place an vanilla farmland next to them, that just work.