Hello,

i noticed that on my Server with Gobber2 installed, the looting enchant doesnt seem to work on the Gobber swords.

I Tried upgrading the version, but that didnt help and i tried looking in the config file for it, but didnt seem to find anything in that direction.

which version of Gobber are you running?

Gobber2-Fabric-1.21-2.10.20 before that i used the Gobber2-Fabric-1.21-2.10.18 version, but i just replaced the mod in the mods folder, maybe i need to do something else aswell?

Im also running the mod MoreGems which also adds some enchantments maybe that could be an issue too?

what enchants are on the sword in question and from which mods?

I tested just looting and it works fine in my setup

Also, post a log so I can see what other mods you are running and if there are any errors

These are the enchants on my Sword
-Sharpness | Standard MC
-Sweeping Edge | Standard MC
-Looting | Standard MC
-Unbreaking | Standard MC
-Mending | Standard MC
-SmithBlade | Gobber
-Experience Boost | Gobber
-Mercy Kill | More Gems (Passive Animals die one shot (might be this one if i think about it))
-Blessing | Gobber
-Razor Sharpness | MoreGems (Adds to the Attack DMG)
-Quickening | MoreGems (Adds boost of power to your attack)
-Wisdom | MoreGems (Recieve more XP)

Log is that one idk if its the right one:
latest.log

What test are you performing to determine that you are NOT getting Looting?

Mercy Kill just deals 100 damage to the animal struck, so I don't think that would affect looting since the animal is killed by the player.

Killing multiple Mobs and always getting the „normal“ Minecraft drop rates without looting as i remember them and I tried getting a wither skeleton head with the sword and in around 100 kills there wasn’t a single head drop, I know it’s rng after all but it was never that rare when I played vanilla before.

I can record a video tomorrow if u want

Ok, I did some controlled test with a similar enchanted sword.

I used an enchanted sword and and unenchanted sword, each killing 10 Pigln

Looting is boosting the amount of drops

also, Looting has no affect on the chance of dropping a skull from a wither skeleton.

BTW: the Nether Sword improves on that last point.

I tried a diamond sword with Looting 3 for comparison. It did a little better, but that could be just a matter of chance.

Interestingly, there is a difference with Looting and passive animals (which is affected by Mercy Kill)
Top 2 rows are drops for 10 cows with crazy enchanted sword like your
Next 2 rows are end sword with Lotting 3 only
bottom line is diamond sword with looting 3

A noticeable difference. Perhaps looting is affected by the overkill damage of the Mercy Kill.

Ahh, good call on suggesting Mercy Kill. I was inflicting damage of generic rather than playerAttack.

Top 2 rows are from crazy enchanted on 10 cows
Next 2 are just Looting 3
Bottom line is diamond with Looting 3

Looks like the crazy enchanted sword performs as one would expect with Looting 3

I will push out an update with the fix

Thanks for reporting.

I was just writing a big answer as I got the email so I’ll just deleted it and keep it short :D

no problem at first I thought maybe I was just trippin or something but I played that much mc that I felt something was off

No Problem, glad I could somewhat help :D

have a nice day/evening/night

I pushed a curseforge update MoreGems 1.7.12 that will fix the issue.