GregTechCEu Modern

GregTechCEu Modern

6M Downloads

Soldering Alloy Dust -> Liquid Soldering Alloy should be Extractor recipe, not a scrap remelting recipe

tomprince opened this issue ยท 10 comments

commented

Checked for existing issues

  • I have checked for existing issues, and have found none.

Tested latest version

  • I have checked that this occurs on the latest version.

GregTech CEu Version

1.20.1-1.5.5 SNAPSHOT 20241206

Minecraft Version

1.20.1

Recipe Viewer Installed

EMI

Environment

Singleplayer

Cross-Mod Interaction

No

Other Installed Mods

Monifactory

Expected Behavior

Recipe is in main extractor category.

Actual Behavior

Recipe is in scrap remelting category.

Steps to Reproduce

Look at the recipe category in EMI.

Additional Information

No response

commented

Also glass -> glass dust should be in the macerator category, not part grinding.

commented

Diamond -> diamond dust should be in the macerator category, not part grinding.

commented

Tungsten ingot -> Liquid tungsten should be extractor.

commented

Vanadium Gallium Ingot -> Liquid Vanadium Gallium should be extractor.

commented

Tin Ingot -> Liquid Tin

commented

(And tin dust -> liquid tin)

commented

Gem (i.e. lapis) -> gem dust should be macerator.

commented

Clay -> clay dust should be macerator.

commented

Note that I am adding comments here as I run into them. My general rule of thumb is that recipes shouldn't be in a specialized category if you are likely to want to create patterns of them, or include them in an EMI recipe tree. Conversely, recipes in specialized categories should be about recycling things that have been overproduced (or outlived their usefulness) back into the more raw form.

Looking over the examples I've found, I think generally any ingot/dust -> anything of the same material should not be in a specialized category.

It also occurs to me that it might be useful to have a specialized centrifuging (and possibly electrolyzing) category for recipes that are the reverse of mixing (i.e. tungsten steel dust -> tungsten dust + steel dust, bisalloy-400 -> component dusts). Those are generally a distraction when looking for how to make tungsten or steel dust.

commented

Sterilizing Filter Casing -> components should be part grinding not macerator