Version Information

Minecraft: 1.12.2
Forge: 2604
Mantle: none
Natura: none
Apple Core: 3.1.0
Hunger Overhaul: 1.3.0 jenkins 139

Report Information

The seed harvesting module seems to be broken, as using the hoe on vanilla grass does de-grass the block, but any time a seed would have spawned errors get thrown at the console (I'm using multimc for testing).

Also, the module is not stopping seeds from dropping from grass.

Steps to Reproduce

"getting seeds" {
    # Adds a crafting recipe to turn 1 wheat into 1 seed [vanilla: false] [default: true]
    B:addSeedsCraftingRecipe=true

    # Each seed has an equal chance to drop (grass drops and via hoes) [vanilla: false] [default: true]
    B:allSeedsEqual=true

    # Multiplier on tool damage taken when a hoe is used ('modifyHoeUse' must be true) [vanilla: 1] [range: 1 ~ 2147483647, default: 5]
    I:hoeToolDamageMultiplier=4

    # Changes the use of hoes depending on the availability of water [vanilla: false] [default: true]
    B:modifyHoeUse=true

    # Whether wood and stone hoe recipes are removed [vanilla: false] [default: true]
    B:removeHoeRecipes=false

    # Removes seed drops when breaking tall grass [vanilla: false] [default: true]
    B:removeTallGrassSeeds=true

    # Percent chance for seed to drop from hoe use on normal difficulty ('modifyHoeUse' must be true) [vanilla: 20] [range: 0 ~ 100, default: 20]
    I:seedChance=25
}

Cheat in a hoe and till some grass away from water.

Forge Log

The errors did not record in the client-latest or the latest logs, but did record in my multimc console.
Console with errors Errors are here!
fml-client-latest.log Errors not present.
Plain latest.log Errors not present.

Bug still valid in HO 131 jenkins 142.

@alexbegt Is there any confirmation on this bug? It seems pretty major that an entire module/feature is completely broken on its own, without other mod interaction. I understand if the fix just takes time to do. Were you able to confirm and reproduce it?

yes confirmed this setting is not working.
# Removes seed drops when breaking tall grass [vanilla: false] [default: true]
B:removeTallGrassSeeds=true
Seeds still drop when breaking grass by hand also seems its been this way ever since 1.8+
Its one the unique things this mod does and one of the main reasons id use it

Came here to report the same thing. This is still an issue in 1.3.3 jenkins 148

addSeedsCraftingRecipe and hoeToolDamageMultiplier work for me. modifyHoeUse will de-grass blocks but will not drop seeds. None of the others seem to work.

HungerOverhaul-1.12.2-1.3.3.jenkins148
forge-1.12.2-14.23.4.2705

Yeah it's unfortunate this still isn't fixed in 2019. BetterWithMod's "HCSeeds" option serves as a good enough replacement for this module fortunately.

B:removeTallGrassSeeds=true will not work, HO don't load the GrasSeedsModule in HungerOverhaul.java

With an activated GrasSeedsModule only 1 seed drop out of >300 try's

Using a hoe give 1 seed out of ~3 try's

I'm not sure why it's commented out, but there must be a reason in one version since MC1.7.10

    @EventHandler
    public void postInit(FMLPostInitializationEvent event)
    {
        //if (Config.removeTallGrassSeeds || Config.allSeedsEqual)
        //{
        //    GrassSeedsModule.postInit();
        //}

        VanillaModule.postInit();
        TweaksModule.postInit();
        VillageModule.postInit();
        LootModule.postInit();

        MinecraftForge.EVENT_BUS.register(new HungerOverhaulEventHook());
        MinecraftForge.EVENT_BUS.register(new RespawnHungerModule());
        MinecraftForge.EVENT_BUS.register(new LootModule());
}

I see this issue has been fixed (like 6 months ago), but curseforge still contains an outdated version. I'd really like to be able to have a functional seed module in my modpack