Unexpected behaviour - exporting with counting filter and with ignore NBT
dm8mydog opened this issue ยท 5 comments
LaserIO version
1.4.5
Minecraft Version
1.18.2
Forge Version
40.2.1
Modpack & Version
ATM7TTS v1.2.2
Do you have optifine installed?
No
Describe the issue
Unexpected behaviour - exporting with counting filter.
Steps to reproduce
This one's a bit quirky.
Use case:
Using a LaserIO node to export from an inventory with large variety of same type of items with NBT data.
In this case: combs from Productive bees ( productivebees:configurable_honeycombs )
I wanted the node to leave some behind of each type, this works fine when the counting filter is specifically set to account for each individual comb within the filter ( but with MATCH NBT).
What am I doing:
However there's a large number of different bee honeycombs from this mod so It ends up saturating all filter slots eventually for a full one side of a node (actually 8 slots out of 9); since I needed the space on that node, I switched it to a simpler catch-all extract with ignore NBT with just one item card with a counting filter. Now the Counting filter 'counts' all items of type productivebees:configurable_honeycombs all in one pool of item count, instead of the individual (different NBT) types.
I expected the counting filter to apply to each individual 'item' (same tag, different NBT) when ignore NBT is activated. It does not.
Sorry, long winded :P
Expected behaviour
Expected the counting filter to apply to each individual item (same tag, different NBT) when ignore NBT is activated. It does not.
Screenshots
No response
Log files
No response
Additional information
No response
Yes but again, if you set it to ignore NBTs it'll think they're all the same items. So it does exactly what you want it to do and removes every Item but one.
Certain items like the honeycombs or for example the prediction matrix from deep mob learbing ARE the same without NBT.
I think the feature you'd need would be something which only counts the items per slot and not per inventory
It's annoying that I myself agree with you on one hand...
...yet on the other hand I have to try and think what different ability the counting filter would bring compared to a non counting filter (in this scenario) and find myself second-guessing myself; and thinking that yeah, it should apply the count on the inventory once each per NBT-variable item...
I dunno which half of me is right! :P
Steps to reproduce
I expected the counting filter to apply to each individual 'item' (same tag, different NBT) when ignore NBT is activated. It does not.
Expected behaviour
Expected the counting filter to apply to each individual item (same tag, different NBT) when ignore NBT is activated. It does not.
I don't quite understand. If you have Items which are only different by NBT, why should it treat them as individual Items if you set Ignore NBT?
Because that's the whole reason to even use a Counting filter, otherwise I'd just use a regular filter instead?
I believe that a counting filter in this scenario should leave one* (or N*-whatever the count is) of each type of NBT-flavoured item back in the source inventory.
