Issue with TownyPerms

Question

Issue with TownyPerms

RubenBarrionuevo opened this issue 6 years ago · 103 comments

RubenBarrionuevo commented 6 years ago

Luckperm in bungee: Yes
Luckperm storage: MySQL
Server: Spigot version: 1.13.2

A few days ago I was using a previous version of LuckPerm.
Due to the fact that each time the version was becoming more dated, we decided to update to the LuckPerms version v4.3.38.

The problem comes when the towny permissions are lost while the users play and suddenly

We have updated to version 4.3.47, but the error continues.

Here is the report I made to the developers of the Towny plugin, in case it could be helpful ->
TownyAdvanced/Towny#3123

In the logs, no error appears about these permissions, I made some verifications with the / lp verbose and some towny permissions are shown as undefined, but this has always been so, I do not understand

lucko commented 6 years ago

Yes.

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 1 · 2018-12-11T00:10:05.000Z

Update: when I use the / lp sync command, it is solved, until the errors return

lucko · Answer 2 · 2018-12-15T21:29:45.000Z

I need more detail to really be able to look into the problem more.

Do you have a specific verbose log that shows LP returning true/false/undefined when it shouldn't be? If you do, we can go from there.

Otherwise, I need more detail about exactly what's wrong. :)

LuckPerms is just a permission plugin, it returns a true/false result based on a number of fairly simple calculations and rules. It shouldn't have any specific compatibility or incompatibility with any plugins in particular (e.g. Towny). It's more likely that some configuration in wrong either with your permissions setup or within Towny itself.

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 3 · 2018-12-15T23:49:30.000Z

Please, look the link -> TownyAdvanced/Towny#3123

LuckPerm and Towny until today had not caused me any error, between both
The towny permissions, I configure it in its corresponding file, which has nothing to do with LuckPerms. However, if you see the / verbose that I did and report in the towny message, you will see how the verbose analyzes a permit that is only established in the towny permits

When I reload the towny plugin, the permissions failures continue.
If I do a / lp sync the permissions work correctly again.

So LuckPerms is interfering in some way with the Towny permits

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 4 · 2018-12-20T22:29:35.000Z

Creo que se estará poniendo en contacto con el desarrollador de towny, no es normal que tarde tanto.

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 5 · 2018-12-20T22:29:53.000Z

Estoy por darle el comando /lp sync a todos los usuarios del servidor xD

LuisGVE · Answer 6 · 2018-12-20T19:58:21.000Z

I have the same problem

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 7 · 2018-12-23T20:14:28.000Z

After a long time trying to cause these failures, I have not achieved it just happens at any time.
There are not a series of steps that by following them cause the error.

Update the network completely to the version of LuckPerm 4.3.58 and the error continues

And it happens exactly what happened to this user, some time ago ->
#1098

It's as if the plugin wants to control the Towny's node, I can not at the beginning but after a while it manages to control the permissions of this plugin

electronicboy · Answer 8 · 2018-12-23T20:16:54.000Z

It's as if the plugin wants to control the Towny's node,
Tasks that require towny to update perm nodes would be a good test, e.g. what happens if somebody joins/leaves a town, does that trigger it?

lucko · Answer 9 · 2018-12-23T21:09:36.000Z

After a long time trying to cause these failures, I have not achieved it just happens at any time.
There are not a series of steps that by following them cause the error.

Ok I appreciate that :)

Will hopefully have some time to look into this in the next few days - probably going to be sometime after Christmas though. ;)

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 10 · 2018-12-23T21:46:18.000Z

OK, perfect
We keep in touch in this case

Enjoy Christmas!

LuisGVE · Answer 11 · 2018-12-23T00:34:22.000Z

@lucko This should be solved by Towny or LuckPerms?

lucko · Answer 12 · 2018-12-23T14:05:06.000Z

From what you've said it does indeed sound like an incompatibility between LuckPerms and Towny, but ideally I need a list of exact reproduction steps.

In other words, what do I need to do in order to make the problem occur?

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 13 · 2018-12-29T23:17:16.000Z

Update the network completely to the version of LuckPerm 4.3.62 and the error continues

lucko · Answer 14 · 2019-01-07T19:01:44.000Z

I need some reproduction steps.

I've downloaded and messed around with Towny a bit, but I have no clue what to do to trigger the issue.

LuisGVE · Answer 15 · 2019-01-07T19:43:59.000Z

World change teleport will reproduce the problem

lucko · Answer 16 · 2019-01-07T20:00:50.000Z

Ok, here's my environment.

> about
[19:56:46 INFO]: This server is running Paper version git-Paper-496 (MC: 1.13.2) (Implementing API version 1.13.2-R0.1-SNAPSHOT)
[19:56:46 INFO]: Checking version, please wait...
[19:56:46 INFO]: You are running the latest version

[19:55:31 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Towny] Version: 0.93.0.0 - Mod Enabled

[19:55:27 INFO]: [LuckPerms] Enabling LuckPerms v4.3.68

No other plugins installed, this is a totally clean server.

I opened the townyperms.yml file and added minecraft.command.gamemode to the nomad section, as follows:

# The 'nomad' permission set covers players not in any town
nomad:
    - towny.command.towny.map
    - towny.command.towny.prices
    - towny.command.towny.tree
    - towny.command.towny.time
    - towny.command.towny.universe
    - towny.command.towny.version
    - towny.command.towny.war
    - towny.command.town.online
    - towny.command.town.here
    - towny.command.town.new
    - towny.command.town.join
    - towny.command.town.list
    - towny.command.plot.perm
    - towny.command.nation.list
    - towny.town.resident
    - towny.town.spawn.public
    - towny.chat.general
    - minecraft.command.gamemode

Then logged into the server, ran /gamemode 1 - command worked successfully, switched worlds to the nether, command still worked.

So, "World change teleport will reproduce the problem" doesn't seem to be causing it.

The sort of detail above is what I need to be able to fix the problem. Specific steps I can go through on a clean server.

LuisGVE · Answer 17 · 2019-01-07T20:23:37.000Z

I have investigated the problem a bit more and there are no steps to be followed to reproduce it, it only happens from one moment to the next. The way to solve it is to change the world, exit and re-join to the server or use '/lp sync' which is very annoying

lucko · Answer 18 · 2019-01-07T20:29:15.000Z

That's unfortunate, but as you can maybe appreciate, I can't really do anything with that information.

LuisGVE · Answer 19 · 2019-01-07T18:46:07.000Z

I have the same problem of permits for a long time... Anything new?

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 20 · 2019-01-08T17:27:54.000Z

The error continues with the version of luckperm 4.3.73

The data that Luis gives you, are partially true, the problems usually occur in the following actions:

When a user changes the world
When a user is invited to a city
When a user leaves a city

And the problems seem to affect only the users involved, that is, while a mayor can enjoy his permissions comfortably, another mayor can be a victim of this error and is deprived of his mayor's commands.

LuisGVE · Answer 21 · 2019-01-09T21:38:39.000Z

@RubenStryker You have discord? We can try to find the problem

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 22 · 2019-01-11T09:07:52.000Z

@LuisGVE sure, of course, my discord nick is @RubenStryker#1256

lucko · Answer 23 · 2019-01-13T16:59:52.000Z

The fix for the above issue might fix this one too.

Would you guys be able to test using v4.3.76 or newer https://luckperms.github.io/

LuisGVE · Answer 24 · 2019-01-16T00:34:47.000Z

This problem continues on the last version

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 25 · 2019-01-16T12:16:44.000Z

Yep, the error continues with the version of luckperm 4.3.76

SmallSansSerif · Answer 26 · 2019-01-18T17:51:47.000Z

Having this problem too. Seems like it started with most recent release.

Yive · Answer 27 · 2019-01-22T14:55:24.000Z

I'm also experiencing this issue. Though I'll test with 4.3.79 once I get the chance. One thing I'd like to notice is that my 1.13.2 server doesn't experience this issue at all which is running build 4.2.89 while my 1.12.2 server is running 4.3.73 which does experience the issue. So there is a possibility that something happened between 4.2.89 and 4.3.x which caused this issue to appear.

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 28 · 2019-01-22T15:01:33.000Z

In this case I think the best option would be to go back to the previous version, in which the failure does not occur

Where can I get this version?

TheFlagCourier · Answer 29 · 2019-01-22T15:10:02.000Z

@RubenStryker You could go to the Release Tags and build against a specific commit, or you could try the version history on the spigot resource page.

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 30 · 2019-01-22T15:12:31.000Z

Thank you very much, tomorrow I will check it

Yive · Answer 31 · 2019-01-22T15:15:09.000Z

It used to be on the jenkins, but sadly it appears the only the 10 most recent builds are kept on there. I had uploaded it onto my server on the 8th of September 2018 so I assume it was based on this commit eca6b09

lucko · Answer 32 · 2019-01-30T16:57:13.000Z

I'm still totally lost with this issue. I've done a number of tests to try to trigger bad behaviour with LP's permission attachment handling - resulting in the fix above - but that still doesn't seem to have fixed the issue.

I've also compared the difference between the current version and the versions that are supposedly fine, but can't really see anything significant.

As I said, I really need steps in the style of this to be able to look any further into this issue.

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 33 · 2019-01-31T00:00:12.000Z

We have already told you the steps that produce it or that seem to produce it (in a margin of 90%).

The last thing you could do, to try to help you find the error, would be to invite it one day that you can to the server.

It is provided with the necessary tools for testing, (configurations, op, rank admin and it indicates the steps to follow so that the error occurs at the moment)

lucko · Answer 34 · 2019-01-31T01:25:20.000Z

Even "keep trying this" x times until the issue appears is fine - I understand it only happens sometimes.

However, I have never used Towny before and don't even know where to start with that. I don't have hours to spend messing around with the plugin just hoping to stumble upon the issue, which is why I need instructions.

Make a clean server, containing only LuckPerms & Towny with default (or very close to default) configs and try to reproduce the issue. If you're able to, explain how and hopefully I'll be able to follow.

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 35 · 2019-02-02T19:59:38.000Z

During this month, I will do everything possible to find the error.
I tried to play it on a clean server, from 0 and I could not reproduce the error.
I am very frustrated, but I will find what causes the error

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 36 · 2019-02-02T20:20:12.000Z

I would like to ask, if as a developer of this plugin you can provide me with certain information, about which plugins may interfere or not be some relevant data that can help me.

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 37 · 2019-02-04T17:47:29.000Z

I think, it can be something related to the use of this bungee plugin with mysql connection

SmallSansSerif · Answer 38 · 2019-02-05T01:06:20.000Z

I'm having this problem too. The Towny dev says it's because of the Luck Perms caching. Does that have any meaning or relevance to this?

lucko · Answer 39 · 2019-02-04T20:37:31.000Z

Very unlikely to be a conflict with another plugin - potentially something that integrates with Towny could affect it?

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 40 · 2019-02-05T11:45:50.000Z

I went back to review all the content of this discussion and I think I will detail again what exactly happens.
After seeing the tests he did, using the gamemode command I can see that he did not do the tests properly. (It should be noted that the command you introduced wrong to not have essentials)

As many of us already know, the towny permissions are assigned in the file townyperms.yml and the permissions in LuckPerm go by a different path

First, I want to emphasize that the errors happen with the permissions that are set in townyperms.yml and are not configured in LuckPerm.
http://towny.palmergames.com/towny/towny-permission-nodes/

Featured example:

Users without a city have the following permission by default:
towny.town.resident
If the user enters a city and then abandons it, he goes back to being without a city, but he stops having the previous permission to join another (This test sometimes has to be tested repeatedly and it is not necessary to change the world)
At this moment if I make a / lp verbose record and I see that in LuckPerms the towny.town.resident permission comes up with the "Denied" label
However, LuckPerms does not have to register these permissions, nor mark them as denied, because these permissions are controlled by the townyperms file
To solve this error, I as a server administrator have only two ways
5.1. Use the / lp sync command (I've had to give it to all the users of the server, otherwise the server is a real chaos)

5.2. Grant the towny.town.resident permission to users through LuckPerm (This way the error with this command would never happen again)
What is the problem?
That there are certain permits, of mayors and assistants that I can not grant through LuckPerm, because they would put at risk the integrity of the cities.

In short, LuckPerm interferes with Towny permissions trying to control permissions that you do not have to control.

The tests I have been able to reproduce on a clean new server with the following plugins:

LuckPerm
Essentials
Vault
Towny
Multiverse-Core

I stress that also what happens with towny.chat permissions if only assigned in the townyperms file.

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 41 · 2019-02-20T11:10:57.000Z

The error continues with version 4.3.94, updated yesterday.
The most affected nodes that LuckPerm tries to control are:

towny.town.spawn.town
towny.town.resident
towny.chat.general
towny.chat.town
towny.chat.local

lucko · Answer 42 · 2019-02-20T11:27:04.000Z

4. However, LuckPerms does not have to register these permissions, nor mark them as denied, because these permissions are controlled by the townyperms file

You're misunderstanding how the townyperms file works. Everything is still controlled through LuckPerms.

Just to reiterate what I've said already:

Even "keep trying this" x times until the issue appears is fine - I understand it only happens sometimes.
However, I have never used Towny before and don't even know where to start with that. I don't have hours to spend messing around with the plugin just hoping to stumble upon the issue, which is why I need instructions.
Make a clean server, containing only LuckPerms & Towny with default (or very close to default) configs and try to reproduce the issue. If you're able to, explain how and hopefully I'll be able to follow.

I need a specific list of steps to follow. I do not know how to use Towny, I've never played a server with it.

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 43 · 2019-02-22T12:56:23.000Z

You're misunderstanding how the townyperms file works. Everything is still controlled through LuckPerms.

I know how the towny permissions works perfectly.

And I keep telling you, that your plugin does not have to control these permissions.
Because in this way LuckPerm can not differentiate between which users have ranges in towny and which do not.

I can not assign permissions of assistant, mayors or other towny ranks through LuckPerm.
https://pastebin.com/hKNFz7QP

I'll take the steps to follow so that an error is reproduced:

Create bungeecord and spigot server and configure them appropriately.
Use MySQL storage and connect both servers to the same db
Also install the plugins: Towny, Vault, Essentials, Multiverse-Core (The latter is not necessary)

Causing the / t spawn error -

You will need a user to create a city.
Invite another user to the city.
The user who joins the city tests the command / t spawn
Repeat these 3 previous steps until the error occurs.

Causing error from nomadic users -

Invite a user to the city
This user stops being nomadic (in towny) and becomes a citizen
Now you take and expel this user from the city.
The user returns to be nomadic, however you can not invite him to another city (according to the author of Towny is because of the LuckPerm cache) because the user continues to maintain his rank of citizen and it is necessary to do a / lp sync

This last case, it has to be repeated, the errors do not appear at the first moment.

And none of these errors occurs if LuckPerm is not installed.

lucko · Answer 44 · 2019-02-22T14:45:58.000Z

And I keep telling you, that your plugin does not have to control these permissions.

It's not doing anything special to "control" them.

Causing the / t spawn error -

Here's a log of me testing the first "error" you described.

I ran though the steps 10 times, worked fine every time.

[14:26:30 INFO]: Done (9.021s)! For help, type "help"
[14:26:30 INFO]: Timings Reset
[14:26:30 INFO]: [TownyChat] -******* TownyChat enabled *******-
[14:26:31 INFO]: [Vault] Checking for Updates ...
[14:26:33 INFO]: [Vault] No new version available
[14:27:46 INFO]: UUID of player Luck is c1d60c50-70b5-4722-8057-87767557e50d
[14:27:49 INFO]: Luck[/127.0.0.1:53842] logged in with entity id 108 at ([world]119.5, 63.0, 195.5)
[14:27:49 WARN]: [Essentials] File motd.txt does not exist. Creating one for you.
[14:27:49 INFO]: [Essentials] Creating empty config: /Users/luck/Desktop/Paper/plugins/Essentials/userdata/c1d60c50-70b5-4722-8057-87767557e50d.yml
[14:29:01 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /towny
[14:29:08 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town create
[14:29:11 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town create test
> eco give Luck 100000
[14:29:19 INFO]: CONSOLE issued server command: /eco give Luck 100000
[14:29:20 INFO]: $100,000 added to Luck account. New balance: $100,000
[14:29:23 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town create test
[14:29:32 ERROR]: --- DO NOT REPORT THIS TO PAPER - THIS IS NOT A BUG OR A CRASH  - git-Paper-527 (MC: 1.13.2) ---
[14:29:32 ERROR]: The server has not responded for 10 seconds! Creating thread dump
[14:29:32 ERROR]: ------------------------------
[14:29:32 ERROR]: Server thread dump (Look for plugins here before reporting to Paper!):
[14:29:33 ERROR]: ------------------------------
[14:29:33 ERROR]: Current Thread: Server thread
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 	PID: 18 | Suspended: false | Native: false | State: RUNNABLE
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 	Stack:
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		java.io.FileOutputStream.write(Native Method)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		java.io.FileOutputStream.write(FileOutputStream.java:290)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		java.io.DataOutputStream.writeInt(DataOutputStream.java:199)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.db.TownyFlatFileSource.savePlotData(TownyFlatFileSource.java:2265)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.regen.TownyRegenAPI.addPlotChunkSnapshot(TownyRegenAPI.java:169)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.command.TownCommand.newTown(TownCommand.java:1912)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.command.TownCommand.newTown(TownCommand.java:1872)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.command.TownCommand.parseTownCommand(TownCommand.java:210)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.command.TownCommand.onCommand(TownCommand.java:120)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		org.bukkit.command.PluginCommand.execute(PluginCommand.java:44)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		org.bukkit.command.SimpleCommandMap.dispatch(SimpleCommandMap.java:149)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		org.bukkit.craftbukkit.v1_13_R2.CraftServer.dispatchCommand(CraftServer.java:734)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.PlayerConnection.handleCommand(PlayerConnection.java:1797)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.PlayerConnection.a(PlayerConnection.java:1605)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.PacketPlayInChat.a(PacketPlayInChat.java:45)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.PacketPlayInChat.a(PacketPlayInChat.java:5)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.PlayerConnectionUtils.lambda$ensureMainThread$0(PlayerConnectionUtils.java:15)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.PlayerConnectionUtils$$Lambda$2143/184920462.run(Unknown Source)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		java.util.concurrent.Executors$RunnableAdapter.call(Executors.java:511)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		java.util.concurrent.FutureTask.run(FutureTask.java:266)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.SystemUtils.a(SystemUtils.java:108)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.MinecraftServer.b(MinecraftServer.java:1011)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.DedicatedServer.b(DedicatedServer.java:439)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.MinecraftServer.a(MinecraftServer.java:938)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		net.minecraft.server.v1_13_R2.MinecraftServer.run(MinecraftServer.java:836)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: 		java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:748)
[14:29:33 ERROR]: ------------------------------
[14:29:33 ERROR]: --- DO NOT REPORT THIS TO PAPER - THIS IS NOT A BUG OR A CRASH ---
[14:29:33 ERROR]: ------------------------------
[14:29:34 INFO]: [Essentials] Creating empty config: /Users/luck/Desktop/Paper/plugins/Essentials/userdata/99f32c9b-1e2f-3b93-ae61-5e69bd262e4a.yml
[14:29:34 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Global Msg] Luck created a new town called test
[14:29:34 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town
[14:29:34 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town
[14:29:34 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town info
[14:30:22 INFO]: UUID of player lucko is 763afb14-1b1a-42d4-acaf-fd88f22e39b3
[14:30:23 INFO]: lucko[/127.0.0.1:53875] logged in with entity id 1876 at ([world]132.5, 63.0, 187.5)
[14:30:23 INFO]: [Essentials] Creating empty config: /Users/luck/Desktop/Paper/plugins/Essentials/userdata/763afb14-1b1a-42d4-acaf-fd88f22e39b3.yml
[14:30:39 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawk
[14:30:41 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:30:48 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town invite lucko
[14:30:48 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:30:55 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:30:55 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:30:56 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:31:00 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:31:01 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:31:04 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t leave
[14:31:04 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko left town
[14:31:06 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:31:08 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town invite lucko
[14:31:08 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:31:15 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:31:15 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:31:16 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:31:18 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:31:23 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t leave
[14:31:23 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko left town
[14:31:29 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:31:33 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town invite lucko
[14:31:33 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:31:37 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:31:37 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:31:38 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:31:40 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:31:46 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t leave
[14:31:46 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko left town
[14:31:49 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:31:53 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town create test
[14:31:54 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town invite lucko
[14:31:54 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:32:00 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:32:00 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:32:01 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:03 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:06 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t leave
[14:32:06 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko left town
[14:32:10 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:13 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town invite lucko
[14:32:13 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:32:17 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:20 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:32:20 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:32:21 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:23 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:25 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t leave
[14:32:25 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko left town
[14:32:26 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:28 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:32 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town invite lucko
[14:32:32 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:32:36 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:32:36 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:32:37 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:40 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t leave
[14:32:40 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko left town
[14:32:41 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:45 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town invite lucko
[14:32:45 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:32:48 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:32:48 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:32:51 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:52 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:32:54 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t leave
[14:32:54 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko left town
[14:32:56 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:33:05 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town invite lucko
[14:33:05 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:33:08 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:33:08 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:33:10 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:33:12 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t leave
[14:33:12 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko left town
[14:33:13 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:33:16 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town invite lucko
[14:33:16 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:33:20 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:33:20 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:33:21 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:33:24 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t leave
[14:33:24 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko left town
[14:33:25 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:33:28 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /town invite lucko
[14:33:28 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:33:33 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:33:33 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:33:42 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn
[14:33:44 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t leave
[14:33:44 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko left town
[14:33:46 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /t spawn

Each time, when the other user was invited to the town, they were able to use /t spawn. When they left, they could not longer use the command.

Causing error from nomadic users -

And here's a log of me testing the second "error". Again, I tried at least 10 times, worked fine each time.

[14:39:49 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:39:49 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:39:54 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:39:54 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:40:02 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t expel lucko
[14:40:08 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:40:08 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:40:11 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:40:11 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:40:13 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:40:13 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:40:16 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:40:16 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:40:17 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:40:17 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:40:19 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:40:19 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:40:21 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:40:21 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:40:23 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:40:23 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:40:25 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:40:25 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:40:32 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:40:32 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:40:37 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:40:38 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:40:39 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:40:39 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:40:42 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:40:42 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:40:43 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:40:43 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:40:46 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:40:46 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:40:49 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:40:53 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:40:53 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:40:54 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:40:54 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:41:05 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:41:05 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:41:07 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:41:07 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:41:10 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:41:10 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:41:12 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:41:12 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:41:14 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:41:14 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:41:15 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:41:15 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:41:17 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:41:17 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:41:19 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:41:19 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:41:20 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:41:20 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:41:22 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:41:22 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:41:24 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:41:24 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:41:25 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:41:25 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:41:27 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:41:27 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:41:30 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:41:30 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:41:31 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:41:31 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:41:32 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:41:32 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:41:35 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:41:35 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:41:35 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:41:35 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:41:40 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:41:40 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:41:43 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:41:43 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:41:43 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:41:43 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:41:45 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:41:46 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!
[14:41:48 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t kick lucko
[14:41:48 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck kicked lucko from town.
[14:41:49 INFO]: Luck issued server command: /t invite lucko
[14:41:49 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: Luck invited lucko to the town.
[14:41:51 INFO]: lucko issued server command: /accept test
[14:41:51 INFO]: [com.palmergames.bukkit.towny.log] [Town Msg] test: lucko joined the town!

Have you actually tried to reproduce the exact steps yourself? As far as I can tell, I have followed your instructions exactly, yet it all seems fine? Unless I've got to try hundreds of times instead of 10?

Did you try running through the steps yourself ensure they would in fact reproduce the issue, or was it just a guess?

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 45 · 2019-02-24T20:08:37.000Z

Do you use MySQL storage using LuckPerm for bungee and for spigot?

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 46 · 2019-02-24T22:53:52.000Z

I start thinking that I'm crazy or something
the next time I try to provoke this error I will document everything as detailed as I can

StpNex · Answer 47 · 2019-03-03T20:29:40.000Z

I have this issue on LuckPerms 4.3.99

I have to use /lp sync everytime so players can for example if they are rank assistant get the assistant nodes on their town..

RubenBarrionuevo · Answer 48 · 2019-03-06T11:49:51.000Z

after several days, in a clean server I have managed to make the errors appear.
However, it is really complicated to occur and even more if the test I'm doing only with 2 accounts.

-> On my test server I can make the error, every, much, much, much time by entering commands

-> In my online server, as the number of users interacting with the plugin is much greater, failures occur with greater ease and speed.

Disappointingly I have not been able to take a series of steps to produce the errors exactly.

And after all the time invested, I will remain attentive to this issue but I am forced to give up my attempts to find the fault, I think it is really complex and I suppose a lot of time.

My solution has been:

Permissions of towny perms that do not belong to towny ranges, I have activated them through LuckPerm to all users.
The powers of rank towny (assistants, mayors, etc.), I have not granted them through luckperm but I have given the option to the users to execute the command / lp sync

I hope it is with a solution, but with more tranquility.
Greetings and luck.

MinecraftAdmin · Answer 49 · 2019-05-01T08:39:32.000Z

Permissions of towny perms that do not belong to towny ranges, I have activated them through LuckPerm to all users.

Would you mind explaining what you mean by that? I am also experiencing this issue and was trying to find a solution, except I am not running LuckPerms with a MySQL database.

JohnS19 · Answer 50 · 2019-10-25T05:47:00.000Z

I would also like to know if there has been any fixes/news regarding this issue.

jakkuh · Answer 51 · 2019-11-23T21:11:44.000Z

Willing to put a $100 USD bounty to get this fixed ASAP.

electronicboy · Answer 52 · 2019-11-23T21:24:51.000Z

This would purely point to some conflict in how lp and towny define perms, I would imagine that an "ez fix" would involve making towny apply it's perms a few moments later, not 100% on how lp would fix this issue directly as it's likely going to be down to the timing of perms being applied

…

On Sat, 23 Nov 2019, 21:11 tivyhosting, ***@***.***> wrote: Willing to put a $100 USD bounty to get this fixed ASAP. — You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#1330>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAJMAZHFT34662ETTA43RVLQVGMBBANCNFSM4GJRUXVA> .

jakkuh · Answer 53 · 2019-11-23T22:30:26.000Z

Okay, I can replicate this both on my regular server and on my test server. Join a town. Just be any towny rank but mayor. (I don't know if mayors ever get the issue or not.) Log in. Try anything that requires perms issued through the townyperms file rather than directly through lp. If it works, log out and relog in. Try again. Repeat until it breaks. This will consistantly work on both my main server and my test server with almost no one in the towny db.
Towny version: 0.93.1.0 Pre-Release 3
[LP] Running LuckPerms v4.4.1 by Luck.
[LP] - Platform: Bukkit
[LP] - Server Brand: Paper
[LP] - Server Version:
[LP] - git-Paper-631 (MC: 1.13.2) - 1.13.2-R0.1-SNAPSHOT
[LP] - Storage:
[LP] - Type: YAML
[LP] - Messaging: None
[LP] - Instance:
[LP] - Static contexts: None
[LP] - Online Players: 1 (2 unique)
[LP] - Uptime: 2d 10h 28m
[LP] - Local Data: 1 users, 60 groups, 4 tracks

My townyperms file from my test server: https://pastebin.com/EsRJfxgJ
On the test server, I was simply testing /t spawn with a regular resident. It took me about 6 relogs to get it to break.
This is what it looks like when broken: (second link is with /lp verbose)
http://prntscr.com/oczu8u
http://prntscr.com/oczven
This is what it looks like after relogging when it works properly again (two links so can show all lp verbose output... there's more here):
http://prntscr.com/oczwf7 http://prntscr.com/oczwzy

On my main server that player is a vip rank in town who has perms to build/break in the town... there I tested for being able to break and it also broke within about 6-10 relogs.

Hopefully this will allow you to replicate the error. You'd also be welcome to test on my test server.

I can confirm that these steps to reproduce do indeed work. The previously mentioned method where switching worlds would break it no longer works (at least in my environment).

MC Version: 1.12.2 (Paper build 1618)
LP Version: LuckPerms 4.4.27
Towny Version: 0.93.1.0 (newest for 1.12.2)

Side Notes:

/lp sync does seem to fix it MOST of the time.
Tested with both MySQL and H2 (no messaging enabled).
Relogging sometimes fixes it, and sometimes the issue persists.
Takes somewhere between 2 and 10 relog attempts before the permission we tested against (/t deposit 1 with node towny.command.town.deposit) would stop working.
We tested "relogging" by going to bungee hub server and coming back to the test server.

lucko · Answer 54 · 2019-11-25T20:33:32.000Z

Should be fixed in version 5.0.6.

lucko · Answer 55 · 2019-12-02T20:32:42.000Z

Closing as I believe this is now resolved.

Thanks everyone for your help :)

SmallSansSerif · Answer 56 · 2020-02-09T20:40:36.000Z

Am now experiencing the Towny/Luckperms desync problem again with LuckPerms version 5.0.72.

I have not tried these versions as I can't find the jars but another Towny admin says v5.0.23 works for them. So assume something changed to bring this back?

lucko · Answer 57 · 2020-03-03T12:01:38.000Z

Nothing significant has changed recently so I'm not sure what would have caused it. I wonder if the issue is with your permissions configuration instead?

JohnS19 · Answer 58 · 2020-03-05T01:35:57.000Z

Not solved for me either.

Momshroom · Answer 59 · 2019-06-08T19:21:34.000Z

I have the same issue, but at lower frequency, and it also started after updating. I am NOT running bungee. I am not using MySQL with LuckPerms. I'm using yaml storage.
I see assistants sometimes not being able to do things in their own towns, etc. Having the player relog fixes the issue. I will try to document better the next time it occurs and see if I'm able to reproduce in a clean environment. That said, it's a rare error and reloading fixes it.

Momshroom · Answer 60 · 2019-06-08T19:57:12.000Z

Okay, player 42Trillian42 was having no issues, relogged and was unable to do /t spawn. There were no console errors.
Lp verbose info for her on that command was the following:
https://pastebin.com/UKNPhq3Q
Lp verbose output for her after relogging again has fixed the issue:
https://pastebin.com/zjkXFfCF
The difference I see is:
[19:49:27] [luckperms-worker-95/INFO]: [LP] VB > 42Trillian42 - towny.town.spawn.town - true
[19:49:27] [luckperms-worker-95/INFO]: [LP] VB > 42Trillian42 - towny.town.spawn.town - true
[19:49:27] [luckperms-worker-95/INFO]: [LP] VB > 42Trillian42 - towny.town.spawn.town - true
[19:49:27] [luckperms-worker-95/INFO]: [LP] VB > 42Trillian42 - towny.town.spawn.town - true
whereas that was false in the check when it was broken... it also made fewer checks.

I don't yet know how to reproduce it, so I'm not sure this will help.

Momshroom · Answer 61 · 2019-06-10T22:56:57.000Z

The output when a town assistant tries to break in town, once again, when he relogs it works properly.

https://pastebin.com/wDuTx6RU

This player says this happens to him EVERY time he logs in the first time after being offline for at least a little while, and relogging always fixes it. Not sure if it's relevant, but he's in a town with 81 residents, 8 assistants and 2969 claimed plots. It's a capital city. Hmm.. Trillian is also in a different capital city, not sure if that's relevant, either.

We're using towny version 0.93.1.0 and Paper 1.13.2, build 628.
Luckperms info output:
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] Running LuckPerms v4.4.1 by Luck.
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Platform: Bukkit
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Server Brand: Paper
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Server Version:
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - git-Paper-628 (MC: 1.13.2) - 1.13.2-R0.1-SNAPSHOT
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Storage:
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Type: YAML
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Messaging: None
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Instance:
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Static contexts: None
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Online Players: 4 (17 unique)
10.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Uptime: 2h 20s
0.06 23:00:44 [Server] INFO [LP] - Local Data: 5 users, 60 groups, 4 tracks

JohnS19 · Answer 62 · 2019-06-13T22:45:21.000Z

Still exists, only fix is either /lp sync or relogging

Momshroom · Answer 63 · 2019-07-04T21:19:08.000Z

We've found another fix... if you remove the player's town rank and then give them the rank again, it fixes them.

Momshroom · Answer 64 · 2019-07-10T08:38:38.000Z

Okay, I can replicate this both on my regular server and on my test server. Join a town. Just be any towny rank but mayor. (I don't know if mayors ever get the issue or not.) Log in. Try anything that requires perms issued through the townyperms file rather than directly through lp. If it works, log out and relog in. Try again. Repeat until it breaks. This will consistantly work on both my main server and my test server with almost no one in the towny db.
Towny version: 0.93.1.0 Pre-Release 3
[LP] Running LuckPerms v4.4.1 by Luck.
[LP] - Platform: Bukkit
[LP] - Server Brand: Paper
[LP] - Server Version:
[LP] - git-Paper-631 (MC: 1.13.2) - 1.13.2-R0.1-SNAPSHOT
[LP] - Storage:
[LP] - Type: YAML
[LP] - Messaging: None
[LP] - Instance:
[LP] - Static contexts: None
[LP] - Online Players: 1 (2 unique)
[LP] - Uptime: 2d 10h 28m
[LP] - Local Data: 1 users, 60 groups, 4 tracks

My townyperms file from my test server: https://pastebin.com/EsRJfxgJ
On the test server, I was simply testing /t spawn with a regular resident. It took me about 6 relogs to get it to break.
This is what it looks like when broken: (second link is with /lp verbose)
http://prntscr.com/oczu8u
http://prntscr.com/oczven
This is what it looks like after relogging when it works properly again (two links so can show all lp verbose output... there's more here):
http://prntscr.com/oczwf7 http://prntscr.com/oczwzy

On my main server that player is a vip rank in town who has perms to build/break in the town... there I tested for being able to break and it also broke within about 6-10 relogs.

Hopefully this will allow you to replicate the error. You'd also be welcome to test on my test server.

Momshroom · Answer 65 · 2019-07-12T04:54:30.000Z

Note: updating to luckperms 4.4.26 seems to have reduced the frequency of the issue for us, but not eliminated it.

lucko · Answer 66 · 2019-07-14T08:22:20.000Z

Ok thank you!

I'm extremely busy at the moment with other "life" things, but I'll hopefully have some time to work more on this issue in the coming weeks.

Drc-DEV · Answer 67 · 2019-10-05T04:02:03.000Z

Any news on this?

Deleted user · Answer 68 · 2020-06-16T22:09:50.000Z

About: A few of the players on my server have complained about not having permission to do certain actions defined in the 'nomad' permission section of Towny. I've been able to workaround this by applying nomad perms to default in LP but now it's not registering the 'default' section in townyperms.yml either. This is the output for the /t here command.

Potentially Helpful: When I was initially creating the server I noticed that this issue didn't appear until I negated the towny.command.town.new permission node. I haven't tested this since to see if it still occurs but it might be useful.

LuckPerms: 5.1.26
Commands Run: /t here

Note: These are the only towny permissions specified on the default rank. What's interesting is that towny.command.town.* is returning false whilst in verbose mode but nowhere in LP did I negate that permission node.

lucko · Answer 69 · 2020-06-18T16:58:56.000Z

Yep I'm keen to see a fix too: in an ideal world, a set of steps required to reproduce the issue would be good - but the nature of the issue makes this tricky. (I've been unable to reproduce the issue on a test server, which makes it very hard to identify what the problem is)

If you can get the bug reliably occurring on your server, I can create some debug jars which you can use to try to pinpoint the problem.

The first fix for this issue was a result of jakkuh kindly doing just that - #1330 (comment)

SirKillian · Answer 70 · 2020-06-18T15:53:58.000Z

@lucko Is there anything we can actually do to help with this issue?

I'm willing to sacrifice some of my time if it's actually something we can fix. As you can see a lot of people have had this issue for a very long time and it is quite frustrating requires a lot of attention to explain to players what is going on.

If it encourages you, I'm willing to spend a decent amount on a proper fix.

SirKillian · Answer 71 · 2020-06-18T17:30:14.000Z

From personal testing experience, it seems to trigger quite often when players change worlds. so I think that would be a good starting point.

I've currently updated towny to its current latest version (0.96.1.12) as well as using current latest Luckperms (5.1.26).

lucko · Answer 72 · 2020-06-21T21:10:26.000Z

I've done some digging around in the classes where the issue was caused before. I think I may have improved things a little and hopefully resolved this bug in the process.

Please give v5.1.62 (or newer) a try - download here: https://luckperms.net/

Relevant commits: 6cb0f5e 21ae1db

ehetteNandaYo · Answer 73 · 2020-06-22T16:27:41.000Z

I've done some digging around in the classes where the issue was caused before. I think I may have improved things a little and hopefully resolved this bug in the process.

Please give v5.1.62 (or newer) a try - download here: https://luckperms.net/

Relevant commits: 6cb0f5e 21ae1db

This actually broke more the issue, my players complained too much today after I updated it

benwoo1110 · Answer 74 · 2020-06-22T16:39:02.000Z

@Nextopi can you provide more details other than its more broken and "my players complained too much today"?

SmallSansSerif · Answer 75 · 2020-06-25T14:38:44.000Z

I decided to update Luckperms post these changes and it's anecdotal but does seem to be de-syncing more frequently.

LuckPerms version 5.1.62
Towny version 0.96.1.14

SirKillian · Answer 76 · 2020-07-01T12:02:51.000Z

After a little bit more research I learned that the issue also appears to happen when members get assigned new town ranks.

So, atm the issue appears to happen when:

Changing worlds
Logging in to the server
Changing a players town rank
Executing /ta reload townyperms

lucko · Answer 77 · 2020-07-02T11:32:13.000Z

Hey all, I've trialled some things here which I think may potentially resolve the issue.

https://github.com/lucko/LuckPerms/compare/remove-nodemap-cache

Here's a build to try: https://we.tl/t-DHzvlpnV7A

ehetteNandaYo · Answer 78 · 2020-07-03T07:09:54.000Z

Tested and issue persists, I just went to another world with warps and came back using /home and permissions werent working.

lucko · Answer 79 · 2020-07-03T17:04:38.000Z

Alright, think I've finally got to the bottom of this issue 😅

adbd2fc

There is a brief explanation above - annoyingly it turned out to be a quirk in the caching library LP uses which I hadn't picked up on. Swapping the library out for my own impl fixes the issue.

Thanks @SirKillian for letting me test on your server.

I would appreciate it if others could confirm the fix works for them too! Anything >= v5.1.72 should have the fix included.

lucko · Answer 80 · 2020-07-05T19:59:37.000Z

I'm assuming the silence is a positive thing..

Thanks again for everyones help. Hopefully closing for good this time!

MinecraftAdmin · Answer 81 · 2020-08-02T01:14:40.000Z

I'm sorry to be the bearer of bad news.
I'm having this issue on LuckPerms 5.1.84 running on MySQL backend, Towny 0.96.2.9 (development build), and Paper 1.16.1

Towny permissions are not applying to a player until they logout and log back in.

Laarryy · Answer 82 · 2020-08-02T01:48:47.000Z

Are other permissions applying? Can you provide steps that work for you every time that will allow us to reproduce the issue?

emkirsh · Answer 83 · 2020-09-07T14:30:16.000Z

Im having this issue as well. Paper 1.16.1, Luckperms MySQL, latest Towny release.

Creativious · Answer 84 · 2020-09-07T19:15:16.000Z

1.16.2 latest releases still don't work

Deleted user · Answer 85 · 2020-09-09T20:06:35.000Z

We updated towny with a bugfix where perms weren't being assigned correctly. We're pushing it as a prerelease to see if that resolves the issue. Keep an eye out for the 0.96.2.17 towny prerelease jar.

ehetteNandaYo · Answer 86 · 2020-03-28T03:14:44.000Z

Is this issue still being worked on? is a very annoying bug,

LuckPerms-5.0.108
paper 1.15.2

BetaBurnt · Answer 87 · 2020-04-23T23:34:21.000Z

Have also started having this issue happen using Paper 1.15.2 #208, LuckPerms 5.0.72 and Towny 0.96.1.6.
No errors from either plugin, "/lp sync" fixes it for a while but then it randomly starts again after a while for no reason.

smqne · Answer 88 · 2020-04-25T12:54:56.000Z

Have also started having this issue happen using Paper 1.15.2 #208, LuckPerms 5.0.72 and Towny 0.96.1.6.
No errors from either plugin, "/lp sync" fixes it for a while but then it randomly starts again after a while for no reason.

Check your LP config. See if 'include-global-world:' is set to false. If it is, set it to true, restart your server, and see if that works.

BetaBurnt · Answer 89 · 2020-04-25T14:27:09.000Z

Have also started having this issue happen using Paper 1.15.2 #208, LuckPerms 5.0.72 and Towny 0.96.1.6.
No errors from either plugin, "/lp sync" fixes it for a while but then it randomly starts again after a while for no reason.

Check your LP config. See if 'include-global-world:' is set to false. If it is, set it to true, restart your server, and see if that works.

Was already set to true when the issue was happening

smqne · Answer 90 · 2020-04-25T14:29:31.000Z

Have you tried updating your plugins? I know that's not the latest paper, I think they released build #213

BetaBurnt · Answer 91 · 2020-04-25T14:32:48.000Z

Have you tried updating your plugins? I know that's not the latest paper, I think they released build #213

At the time of my post that was the latest Paper build - the server is updated regularly, is now on the latest build (#214) and still has the same issue that is only fixed by using "/lp sync" which is only temporary and it starts again randomly after a while.

smqne · Answer 92 · 2020-04-25T14:35:11.000Z

Have you tried disabling plugins one by one to see if any are conflicting each other?

SmallSansSerif · Answer 93 · 2020-04-25T16:12:06.000Z

This is an ongoing bug on Towny servers. Still have this too. See lots of background above. I use lp sync every 3-5 mins on an auto schedule to help.

KarlOfDuty · Answer 94 · 2020-04-26T19:27:21.000Z

Yeah, not sure why this is closed. We have had this for at least a year and it has not been fixed yet.

ehetteNandaYo · Answer 95 · 2020-04-27T17:54:13.000Z

@lucko any chance to get a fix for this?

lucko · Answer 96 · 2020-04-28T11:42:02.000Z

This was closed because as far as I know the issue was fixed, but seems we're back to the start.

I need details reproduction steps to be able to do anything to fix the problem. (in a similar style/detail to this)

dorsax · Answer 97 · 2020-05-24T19:00:17.000Z

Due to the randomness of the issue it is not likely to give any reproductive steps without knowing how to search for them. The only help I can offer is direct access to our live server and notifications when the issue happens. But it happens about one in five times anyone logs in without the wildcard permission. And because they cannot sync anything they have to log off and on.

lucko · Answer 98 · 2020-05-27T17:10:20.000Z

Sure that works!

dorsax · Answer 99 · 2020-05-29T16:12:18.000Z

Feel free to join the server on mc.doktorfroid.de

Please contact me via Discord, dor_sax#8882 (I am on your DC Server, too), when you need anything like granting rights or forwarding notifications to you incl. logs, configs, etc.

Share to