Description

Can't negate minecraft command permissions

Reproduction Steps

Whilst opped:

1. Try /gamemode creative (works)
2. do /lp user <you> permission set minecraft.command.gamemode false
3. Try /gamemode creative again. Works when it shouldn't

Doing /lp verbose command me gamemode says false as expected and also gives the no permission message

Expected Behaviour

Actually negate minecraft permissions

Server Details

git-Paper-484 (MC: 1.19.4) (Git: 7a96bf2)

LuckPerms Version

v5.4.71

Logs and Configs

No response

Extra Details

No response

Seems like being opped causes the permission to not be checked, this is probably a Bukkit/Spigot/Paper issue

I think this can be solved by using the ignore-vanilla-permissions setting in commands.yml on craftbukkit/spigot/paper. This setting basically removes the "op level" check for permissions, so only the bukkit permissions is checked.

The issue is that an opped player has a permission level (1-4). When the game goes to check if a player can use a vanilla command, first the op level check is done. If that fails, the bukkit permission is checked. The above setting just makes the first op level check ignored.