Mekanism

Mekanism

111M Downloads

Energy cube side orientation depends on player view when placed

Spongman opened this issue ยท 8 comments

commented

Issue description

(FTB Skies 1.2.1)

unlike every other Mekanism block, for an Energy Cube "Top" is not always in the negative-y direction.

If I look vertically up and place an Energy Cube on the ceiling, then "Front" is the side pointing towards the floor.

In what universe does this make sense? Why are Energy Cubes different from all other machines?

Steps to reproduce

No response

Minecraft version

1.19.2 (Latest)

Forge version

43.2.11

Mekanism version

Current Dev Branch (Manually Compiled)

Other relevant versions

No response

If a (crash)log is relevant for this issue, link it here: (It's almost always relevant)

No response

commented

It is a six directional block the same as the quantum entangloporter, lasers, and various other blocks in the mod.

commented

that's dumb. in what universe does "Top" not mean "toward the sky" ?

image

Especially for something that looks that same from all sides?

person A: "what side is the top of this box here"
person B: "this one, surely, the one on top?"
person A: "oh, no, actually the 'Top' side is this one on the side here, because the person who put the box down was looking down when they placed it."
person B: "are you insane?"

Just because it's also broken for other blocks, doesn't mean it's not broken. It just means it's broken for those blocks, too.

commented

Top is the top side of the block which respects the placed Direction.
Top is a relative direction, always referring the blocks placed direction.

Side fact
"Up" would be a cardinal direction, but mekanism does not use cardinal directions in this context.

So always remember how you placed the block or place it in a predictable way(for example if you place it in your wall already full of machines, place the block from the front of the wall)

commented

Yeah, i understand how it works now. I'm just saying that it doesn't make any sense for something that looks the same from all sides to have a "top" direction that isn't "up".

The only time IRL this happens is when something is placed on its side and it's obvious by looking at it that it's wrong.

commented

Top isn't up
Top is relative and up is cardinal

I can understand that a directional block with the same textures can be confusing but note that the block model adapts to the configuration mode of the side. If right is toggled disable, the port vanishes on the right

commented

yeah, you keep saying the same thing "this is how it works"

i'm saying that that doesn't make any senes.

commented

What does not make any sense? The directions are used, the model adapts to the side configuration

The model how it is now would not work if the block isn't directional

commented

What does not make any sense

please read my previous comments. the answer to this question should be obvious from what i wrote.

Maybe "top" and "up" mean something different for you?