MineColonies

MineColonies

53M Downloads

Crafting warehouse conflit [$5]

RedAlex opened this issue · 18 comments

commented

Minecolonies version minecolonies-universal-1.11-0.6.2919

Minecraft version 1.11.2

Forge Version 13.20.0.2252

Expected behavior

  • Crafting warehouse cube with Wood and chest in middle

Actual behaviour

  • With the recipe to create Warehouse are the same of Cabinet (Mod MrCrayfish's Furniture)

Did you help close this issue? Go claim the $5 bounty on Bountysource.

commented

Well, that's unavoidable and is NOT a mod issue. It's a "conflict" of recipes which is very common. Issue should be closed IMO, nothing to do here?

commented
commented

There is a mod for disambiguating recipes, it's appropriately called, NoMoreRecipeConflict.

commented

Well if there is a system to create recipes with a bounty I'm guessing it will include ALL recipes?

commented

Any appetite for making our own crafting bench block for our mod and making colony chests only craftable in that? - Can be supplied as part of the supply chest.

commented
commented

You could would be simple enough
Should i take a look at later tonight?

commented
commented

Just make the build tool the only thing that requires common materials. I guess there will be only one potential for conflict there.

However, it might not be simple.
Since some recipes take up 9 slots, adding one more required item would change many of these.

Also if the npcs will be able to craft both mod items and vanilla items at some point, they must also have this build tool too or some special condition must be set for the crafting table or npc.

commented

Yeah i already dug into it.
It is fairly simple to change. However i am still looking into it.

I have exams right now, if somebody else wants to take a look he is more then welcome.

commented
commented
commented

How about the crafting recipes be a vertical stack of [Builder's Wand] [Unique Item] [Chest] where the unique item is something related to the hut?

commented

+1

commented

kk.. anyone made progress with it? So I can add/replace all the WIKI recipes as soon as it's avail.

I agree all the recipes as they are, are fine just add the building tool in the top center block.

If there is a material there substitute it w/building tool, if empty just add building tool.

Building tool always returns to player's Inventory after crafting.

Crafting recipe is 2 sticks and 1 cobble, simple.
https://wiki.minecolonies.com/wiki/1/recipes

commented

No need to return the build tool as it is cheap to make

commented

I would be pretty annoyed to have to keep remaking it for every building.
It changes from needing a shovel to make a building, to you need a shovel embedded into every building.
The same way you need a bucket of milk to make a cake, but the bucket itself is not apart of the cake.
I know the analogy is not perfect, but hopefully close enough.

commented

build tool is cheap, don't know how to return an item, so the recipe will consume it