I'm a player in the Minecraft Comes Alive Server and I've noticed along with other players that the villagers will not breed. They also will not breed when given cake. It does not take both cake from my inventory and only takes one. I even have gifted the other cake to the other spouse and it still didn't work. I gave two cakes to one spouse and that didn't work either. Thank you.

-A Dedicated Fan

Gifting cake to villagers will not work 100% of the time.