Oh The Biomes You'll Go Refabricated

Oh The Biomes You'll Go Refabricated

12M Downloads

[1.19][Crash]: New version of BYG crashes with Croptopia on Quilt when trying to create a new world or opening an existing save

SatDog92 opened this issue ยท 6 comments

commented

BYG Version

2.0.0.12

Terrablender Version

2.0.1.128

Mod Loader

Quilt

Mod Loader Version

0.17.13

What happened?

Apparently, when BYG is loaded with Croptopia, the game crashes as soon as you open an existing save or when you try to open the "Create New World" page. This does not happen on Fabric, only on Quilt. Previous 2.0.0.11 BYG version didn't have this issue, as i've used BYG with many other mods without game breaking issues, it only happens with this 2.0.0.12 one.

crash-log

crash-2022-10-10_13.15.35-client.txt when opening save.
crash-2022-10-10_13.38.47-client.txt when trying to access the Create New World page.

latest.log

latest.log

Did you isolate BYG?

I tried BYG alone (along with Croptopia to demonstrate the issue that didn't exist before)

commented

Also have the same issue.

commented

Hi!

I have looked a bit over the code of both projects.

I can confirm that this is not caused by BYG!
It is caused by Croptopia not using the proper APIs, leading to random incompatibilities.

If this behavior has not manifested before it's because BYG recently changed its mixins to using the APIs for making blocks strippable, in the old code BYG was making the map mutable without remaking it immutable, Croptopia on the other hand does something similar but keeps the immutability.
Before the bug might have been hidden by BYG applying its changes after Croptopia.

This issue should be reported to Croptopia instead.

commented

Thank you for the detailed description of the issue, i'll head to the Croptopia's issues page for this instead.

commented

Same issue but on Fabric not Quilt

commented

Same issue but on Fabric not Quilt

Most likely your issue on certain settings, can confirm Fabric doesn't make Croptopia crash with Byg.

commented

Most likely your issue on certain settings, can confirm Fabric doesn't make Croptopia crash with Byg.

This issue occurs with specific load orders and mod sets, so this could happen on Fabric as well.