Open Terrain Generator (OTG)

Open Terrain Generator (OTG)

10M Downloads

Bug: Vanilla structures spawn above bo3s if there is an overlapping x and z coordinates.

FrankTCA opened this issue ยท 3 comments

commented

OTG Plugin or Mod

  • OTG Mod for Forge
  • OTG Plugin for Spigot

OTG Version

  • 1.12.2_v8_r1
  • 1.12.2_v7_DEV_r26
  • 1.12.2-v6
  • 1.12.2-v5
  • 1.11.2-v8
  • 1.11.2-v9
  • 1.10.2-v21
  • Other - specify here - OTG 1.16

Forge or Spigot Versions

purpur-1.16.5-1171

What other plugins are you running?

Chunky, CoordinatesHud, DeathHold, DiscordSRV, DropsOverhaul, dynmap, Dynmap-Essentials, Essentials, EssentialsChat, EssentialsProtect, EssentialsSpawn, ImageOnMap, LuckPerms, mcMMO, OldCombatMechanics, PlugMan, ProtocolLib, RealisticSeasons, SilkSpawners, Vault, VeinMiner, ViaVersion, Vivecraft-Spigot-Extensions, and, of course, OTG.

Description

We discovered a village farm that spawned on top of a tree. This leads me to believe that vanilla structures will spawn above bo3s.
Screenshot

I would say that most likely what should be happening is either the bo3 or the vanilla structure should be canceling.

Make a world with an endless supply of commonly occurring simple bo3s. Make sure villages and other structures are enabled and wait for it to occur.

commented

Vanilla structures like villages actually affect base terrain generation and manipulate the noise to create platforms on which they can spawn, we refer to this as noise-based-smoothing for structures. Some vanilla structures (or parts of vanilla structures) apparently do height checks during decoration, in which case resource layering problems like this may occur. We'll see if this still happens after we switch to 3x3 decoration, I have a hunch it might still happen even then though.

commented

So that means this is a won't fix?

commented

Dead issue, will wait till we switch to 3x3 and see if it fixes, until then, this is won't fix.