Item quantity quirk (1.6)
brisingraerowing opened this issue ยท 32 comments
Issue description:
Grids show a minimum of 96 items, even if only one of any item is in the system.
What happens:
Grid shows more items than it should.
What you expected to happen:
Grid shows actual amount of items.
Steps to reproduce:
- Put items in the system.
2.... - Weird numbering.
...
Version (make sure you are on the latest version before reporting):
- Minecraft: 1.12.2
- Forge: 2739
- Refined Storage: 1.6
Does this issue occur on a server? [yes/no] Untested.
If a (crash)log is relevant for this issue, link it here:
It appears that RS is duplicating the item data over all disks in the system. I am using Reborn Storage disks, so this may be on their end. The actual number of items in the system is correct (e.g. if a single wheat is put it, you can only pull one out).
Are you sure these items are on a disk? Aren't they in an external storage?
Can you reproduce this with an empty RS network? (1 storage disk, a controller, a grid)
The ones in external storage (storage drawers) show fine. I disconnected the storage drawers and it still did this. It seems to be related to the number of disks in the system (I had 96 disks). I'll do some testing.
It happens as soon as I connect an external storage, even if there's nothing in it.
Also, give me exact reproduction steps (starting off an empty system). What do I have to do, place, etc.
Any kind of inventory can be connected.
Simply set up an RS system with some disks (> 1) and put a single item in it. Then place some kind of inventory (e.g. a chest) and attach it to the system with an External Storage. The item in the system should now show the quantity as the number of disks in the system.
Are you sure your reproduction steps are correct? Did you try to follow your own steps?
@brisingraerowing I just tried the exact same setup with Reborn Storage, and I can't reproduce it?
Can you, please, be more specific? This is getting frustrating.
Weird it is. Something's messed up in my instance. I'll try rebuilding it and see what happens.
Still happens even after a complete recreation of that instance. Something is messed up. Might be an issue with MultiMC itself. I'll try rebuilding my entire setup.
Even a complete nuke and rebuild of my setup didn't fix it. I'm at a loss as to what could be broken.
I was able to replicate this with just RS. Here's an image of my testing setup:
The external storage needs to be added last. There are 8 64K disks in the drive.
The item that gets 'duplicated' needs to be in the system before the external storage is added, BTW. Anything added after doesn't duplicate unless another ES is added.
Weird:
My flow:
- Place Controller
- Place Disk Drive
- Place Grid
- Insert 8 64k disks into disk drive
- Insert 1 chest into the Grid
- Place chest
- Connect External Storage
I was able to reproduce this too
You must update any block from your RS system (e.g. Disk Drive or External Storage)
It seems to be a block-update visual bug
Minecraft Setup:
Minecraft: 1.12.2
Forge: 1.12.2-14.23.4.2739
Refined Storage: 1.6.2-256
Update
Also tried with 1.6.3-258
Well, at least someone else has figured something out. This was beginning to run me up the wall. I even did a refresh of my Win10 install to see if that would work (I needed to do one anyways as I had accumulated a ton of crap since the last time I did a refresh. My system runs about 90% faster now).
I just noticed something. When this issue occurs, ALL of the disks get the same UUID. I'm guessing that's the core of this issue.
I still can't reproduce the issue. I'm suspecting (aka i'm almost sure) that you guys aren't running a RS vanilla instance to test this.
See my post above.
Are you running any other mods in the testing instance?
How did you obtain those disks? Did you create unique ones or duplicate them with middle click (so they end up having the same ID)