Scaling Health

Scaling Health

Mods
23M Downloads

Scaling Health causes damage indicators to show incorrect values by adding 1 more health to every mob

iWERTSQ opened this issue ยท 1 comments

commented

Versions

  • Scaling Health: ScalingHealth-1.12.2-1.3.38+143
  • Silent Lib: SilentLib-1.12.2-3.0.13+167
  • Forge: forge1.12.2-14.23.5.2838
  • Modpack: Custom

Expected behavior

  • Current health should exactly be equal to the max health when mobs first spawn.

  • For example: Sheep should spawn with 8 health and if they get hit 8 times by hand, they should die.

Actual behaviour

  • Current health when mobs first spawn is always 1 more than max health, which makes no sense. (9/8, 11/10 etc.)

  • For example: Sheep should spawn with 8 health and have max of 8 health. Instead, they have 9 CURRENT HEALTH and 8 MAX HEALTH which makes no sense. You have to hit them 9 times instead of 8.

  • No matter what mod that mob is from, this happens to every mob and causes damage indicators mods to show incorrect values of health.

  • The issue has been tested with and without other mods and scaling health was the one that caused the problem only.

  • Depending on what damage indicator you're using, there are 2 possible ways to see this issue:

    • Mods such as The One Probe will first show sheep's health as 8/8 but when they get hit 8 times, it will still show 0/8 and then if you hit one more time, the mob will die.
    • Mods such as ToroHud will show sheep's health as 9/8.

    Either way, scaling health causes damage indicators to fail.

Links/Images

Some of the mobs to illustrate the issue (look at the top left corner to see the health values):

Steps to reproduce the problem

Install Scaling Health and any damage indicator mod. No need to change config.
commented

This would be an issue with Damage Indicators. My guess is they are rounding up current health, but truncating (rounding down) max health. Note that health values in Minecraft are not whole numbers. This is also why you can see 0 health from TOP. The mod must be truncating health values. Either way there's nothing I can do to fix this.