So I heard you were talking crap about Minecraft's difficulty?

So I heard you were talking crap about Minecraft's difficulty?

797k Downloads

Wrong blocks tags/id with other mods (v1.10.4)

Toimis opened this issue ยท 9 comments

commented

Hello,

I play with a decently large modpack and noticed at some point after updating mods that my friends were experiencing issues. It seemed like blocks had ID mismatches or something, causing them to appear as waterlogged or as entirely different blocks for them, but normal for me (since I play singleplayer and open the world using Essential when they have time to play).

The issue is reproducible for me with only Fabric API, SIHYWTCAMD, and Wilder Wild. If you join a random server (I used Hypixel), you will notice some crazy stuff happening. I have not tried reproducing on a fresh install, so it's probably a lost cause if you cannot because I had over 100 mods at some point lol.

I will also be reporting this issue to the Wilder Wild repository.

Thank you!

PS: Love the mod, and appreciate the work you put in!
Screenshot 2024-08-21 051924
Screenshot 2024-08-21 051727
latest.log

commented

Hi, thanks for the report! This looks like the same issue than #56. The player just updated other mods and it seemed to fix its issue. I will try to reproduce with wilderwild though to know if there is something more

commented

Hi, I've done a little bit of testing. I didn't reproduce on singleplayer but I did on server. However, I encountered the issue only when I had Wilder Wild installed. Difficulty only did not seem to create block mismatches (maybe it did but as I add only one block, maybe only one is mismatched). Anyway, I think the issue you're having with your friends is that you're not playing with the same mods setup in terms of mods adding new blocks, either missing mods or different versions. Can you confirm?

commented

No, we all play with the same mods using my GitHub repository found here: https://github.com/Toimis/MC1.21

And this batch script I made with AI lol
update2.txt

commented

If you join a random server (I used Hypixel), you will notice some crazy stuff happening

Content mods change the registered blocks and renderers. If you join a non-fabric server that does not sync that data (like hypixel), then your game will render blocks incorrectly. This is why mismatched mod versions can cause the issue as well. This is not an issue with this mod nor wilder wilds, its a problem with trying to use mods on servers with different or missing mods

commented

This is not an issue with this mod nor wilder wilds, its a problem with trying to use mods on servers with different or missing mods

I was having this issue even with my friends, who sync their mods completely the same though? Is it because of something with Essential hosting? I'm going to start using Aternos or port-forwarding so I'll see what I can find out, but everyone else stopped playing

Edit: Actually, there should only be 2 mods, CameraOverhaul and Chunky (which I have client-sided for myself), that are different from everyone else. I still don't think that's the issue though.

commented

Having client-side mods is not the issue. As we both mentioned, the issue should come from different (server) mods registering new blocks and/or different configs. If you all have the exact same configs for the exact same (server) mods, then the issue might come from Essential that doesn't sync properly the data when opening the multiplayer.

commented

I don't know how you setup your server, but you're either doing it wrong or not installing only Difficulty and Biomes o Plenty. I did the test again and it works perfectly fine when joining a Fabric server that has the same mods and config than the client.

The 1.10.4 version is absolutely not incompatible with 1.21 as it was made for this version. Minecraft 1.21.1 has nothing to do with it, it's just a minor version that only added a hotfix for an important bug.

Feel free to share your server setup here, so I can eventually tell you what's wrong and/or understand the issue, as I can't reproduce it for now

commented

Sorry for the lack of progress, but my friends stopped playing Minecraft, so I did too. If I come back to it sometime, I will probably be using your mod again. I'll let you know if I have any issues then, since many mods will be updated by then, but downgrading is a suitable solution for me.

Not sure if anyone else is having this particular issue with 1.10.4 in 1.21, so you can keep it open to see if anyone else replies or you can close it. Thanks for your help anyways!

commented

Keep me in touch :)