Silent Gear

Silent Gear

Mods
30M Downloads

1.17.1 Fishing rod immediately returns after casting, unable to fish

GhostieEcho opened this issue ยท 2 comments

commented

Versions

Minecraft 1.17.1

  • Silent Gear: 2.7.2
  • Silent's Gems: 4.1.2
  • Silent Lib: 5.0.0
  • Forge: 37.0.50
  • Modpack: N/A
  • Optifine Installed: Yes

Expected Behavior

Floatie to go out onto the water, bob like usual, catch fish.

Actual Behavior

Floatie immediately comes back in, unable to fish. Built a vanilla fishing rod to test, and it works as intended.

My Silentgear fishing rod is built with Iron main, Birch rod, and fluffy string bowstring.

Same result with a fishing made with birch main, string bowstring, and stone rod.

Steps to Reproduce the Problem

  1. Build a fishing rod like mine.
  2. Go to a lake etc
  3. Try to fish.
commented

Mostly just some notes for myself: Seems to be caused by some vanilla code that kills the fishing hook entity whenever the held item is not a vanilla fishing rod. I think the only solution right now since we have no Mixins would be to extend the FishingHook entity and override the relevant method.

commented

Oh is THAT why everyone has the same trouble with custom fishing rods? useful knowledge!