Spice of Fabric (Fabric)

Spice of Fabric (Fabric)

593k Downloads

SoF 1.16.5 crash

nxghtmvrx opened this issue ยท 4 comments

commented

Client crash on start
Let me know if this should be reported on the side of other mod instead.

commented

Hello, I got the same problem.

The problem persist with any version of AppleSkin, and if we remove AppleSkin, it works. But we need to have AppleSkin for this mod. So can you fix this for the 1.16.5 ? Or tell us the problem ?

Thanks in advance.

Here's my crash report : crash-2021-09-18_10.11.39-client.txt

commented

AppleSkin 1.0.11 works without crash. At this point I think Fabric is the one to blame whether it is due to internal changes between 1.16.*-1.16.5 or incompatibility because of mods expecting different versions of the same embedded/required components.

Sadly if you want to have all the best mods together right now the only solution is to juggle all of 1.16.* versions of the updated mod causing this crash by hand and figure out which of non-latest was stable.

commented

@nxghtmvrx You're pretty right there, but Fabric is not the one to blame ^^

To summarize:

When Spice of Fabric was mainly developed, AppleSkin had no official API that SoF could hook into. Therefor I needed to mixin (adapt the code of) to AppleSkin.

Pretty recently AppleSkin update to 2.0 and with that they changed the related parts of the code and exposed an API.

SoF has the correct changes in the 1.17 version, but I currently do not intend to do backporting for SoF.

If you want to play with both mods, you basically got two options:

  1. Update to Minecraft 1.17 and use the latest versions.
  2. Stay on Minecraft 1.16 with an AppleSkin version below 2.
commented

Since we're now three major versions away from Minecraft 1.16, I'm gonna close this issue.