After having reached the maximum number of hearts there are currently no longer items relabeled to eaten, which makes sense, since it sais "Eaten: Assisted in adding hearts", but it'd be nice to see other already eaten items marked as such or even as "Eaten.", which could be added when the config changes.

It seems as if there was weirdness going on: With default config it did stop marking food, after my change to 64 items (totaly arbitrary power of 2), it did mark my grape salad as eaten. I am totaly confused by this mod. At least the issue fixed itself.