Storage Drawers: Forestry Pack

Storage Drawers: Forestry Pack

6M Downloads

[1.12] Can't extract items from drawer with creative vending upgrade

boop5 opened this issue · 17 comments

commented

Expectation: I want to transfer unlimited items from my drawer to any inventory.
Reality: No items get transferred at all.

Example Setup.
setup
servo

Playing on ATM3 4.2 with StorageDrawers-1.12.1-5.3.3
Tried Thermal Expansion Itemducts and Extra Utilities 2 Transfer Node

commented

I have experienced the same issue. Same pack - except my setup was several drawers with creative vending upgrade in, I then connected Refined storage to the controller, it could see the inventory, but refused to pull out. AE2 had exactly the same issue.

commented

I've got the exact same problem in "All the mods 3"

  • StorageDrawers-1.12.1-5.3.3
  • StorageDrawersExtras-1.12-3.1.0

Only way I was able to extract from the drawer is with the creative vending upgrade is using IC2 with the pull upgrade.
tried several different mods to extract from the drawer without any luck.

commented

I'm seeing the same issue, but even other players cannot access the items. It seems like any method of extraction that is not manually by the original player seems to fail. (I was using a drawer with a vending upgrade to offer some starter items to new players).

commented

Same issue here in the Horizons 3 modpack

commented

aaaand same issue in forever stranded lost souls, version 5.3.4

commented

What version of the mod are you on?

commented

Woopsie. Forgot to add this to my original post

Playing on 5.3.3

commented

Has this still not been fixed? I see no reason for this issue to even exist. Please prioritize.

commented

I used the Creative Cache from TeamCOFH's Thermal Series of mods. A creative cache becomes an infinity dispenser and works with Refined Storage and item ducts.

commented

@GreyMario a valid criticism. I've been on a modding break with a bunch of other deadlines, so I'm trying to break back into maintenance of the mod now. I'm sure I looked at this when it was first reported and couldn't reproduce at the time. We'll see if it's any different now.

commented

Heh, I looked back at the original file date and realized this was just a few days before I moved. Anyway, it sucks that I let it go ignored for so long because it seems to have been an easy fix.

I haven't combed through the backlog of other issues yet, but I put up a new version with this fix, 5.3.8.

commented
commented

Oof. Timing issue. Shit happens, I suppose.

Thank you for fixing this. Now to convince all of the pack developers that they need to actually keep up with updating packs every once in a while...

commented

Upon further inspection, I've reproduced the problem with a minimal setup:

  • Place a creative vending upgrade in an empty compacting drawer
  • Put any item in the compacting drawer
  • Connect the drawer to a ME Controller with a Storage Bus
  • You will be unable to take items out of the drawer via a ME Crafting Terminal (piping items via other methods such as EnderIO Item Conduits works)

I cannot reproduce this issue with regular drawers.

Also one thing to note, if you put a few items in a compacting drawer and then put the creative vending upgrade in, you'll be able to take that exact amount of items out of the drawer via the ME network, and after you've taken out that many items the drawer becomes cleared out and displays no item if the drawer was unlocked.

So here's what it looks like to me:

  • The problem appears to be isolated to compacting drawers.
  • Taking items out of a compacting drawer through and ME network, even with the creative vending upgrade, removes the actual items from the drawer that were there before installing the vending upgrade.
  • Adding items to a compacting drawer after installing a vending upgrade voids the items, so that there is nothing actually in the drawer (this is probably intended).

Would you like me to create a separate ticket?

commented

I'm seeing this issue in Enigmatica 2: Expert, using 5.3.8

commented

Also an issue in Modern Skyblock 3 Pack Version: 3.4.1.4 Mod Version: 1.12.2-5.3.6

commented

Has there been any new insight here?
The creative vending upgrade works when I manually remove items but Refined Storage and Thermal Dynamics methods cannot extract items.

I'm trying to create a map for my students in which I wish to keep some items stocked without having to manually refill the bins.