The default compacting drawer recipe only accepts oak drawers (full, half, half 1x2, half 2x2) as the drawer required for compacting drawers even if Storage Drawers Extras is included. I have made note of this issue in my tracker for my latest modpack. As a work around I will try to edit the recipe in Craft Tweaker 2 to allow any storage drawer and distribute that with the next update.

Forgot to give versions, sorry:
MC 1.12.2
Forge 14.23.5.2847
Storage Drawers 5.4.1
Storage Drawers Extras 3.1.0

Closing this since it's not even being addressed. Sorry to trouble the devs.