Thaumic Augmentation

Thaumic Augmentation

7M Downloads

Primal Cutter shouldn't be enchantable with Sweeping Edge

Turkey9002 opened this issue ยท 8 comments

commented

It's currently possible to enchant the primal cutter with sweeping edge from the enchantment table or using enchanted books in the anvil. The problem is it would have no effect on the weapon because the weapon itself cannot do sweep attacks.

commented

Shouldn't the bug be that the Primal Cutter doesn't do sweep attacks? If it says it's a sword in the description, shouldn't it behave like a sword with the sweep attack?

If there's no way to fix that, then yeah, dropping the Sweeping Edge eligibility for the Primal Cutter makes sense.

commented

I actually thought it was intentional for it to not have sweep attacks, but now after you mention that I'm not entirely sure. XD I think it's much easier to just restrict it because the sweep attack itself is hard coded to the sword tool and the code for the cutter would have to extend it to be able to add that feature. I think doing that might affect it's multi-tool use though.

commented

You are exactly right, it looks like Minecraft only enables sweep attacks for things that are swords, but technically the primal cutter is just a tool with high damage. If I'm feeling adventurous I can make a coremod patch to fix that, otherwise I might disable it.

commented

I was able to add sweep attacks to the cutter, so in the next update sweeping edge will actually work as intended on it.

commented

I can also confirm that the cutter from creative mode at least doesn't have the sweep working.

commented

Should be reopened, the feature isn't working in the version downloadable on CF:
https://imgur.com/a/7eevAw4

commented

Sorry about that, I'll be reuploading that version shortly with this actually working

commented

Sweep attack and sweeping edge enchant both work with no issues! ๐Ÿ‘