I think it may have to do with lag but here's my log if that helps idk i just can't seem to catch fish in my server and the constant avg tick is like 120 ms.
latest.log
i notice right before im about to reel in a fish, it gives me a log error or something and then it always makes the fish missing noise even tho i tried my best to time it.

According to your log, you are running tide 1.0.0, which isn't supported anymore.

This same issue should be fixed as of 1.3.2 and up!