Tinkers Construct

Tinkers Construct

160M Downloads

Molten stone

InventionIO opened this issue ยท 15 comments

commented

Minecraft Version

1.16.5

Forge Version

36.2.19

Mantle Version

dont know, what it is. 1.6.147

Tinkers' Construct Version

... whats the latest ? 3.3.0.308

Problem description

you cant melt stone tools

Suggested solution

add liquid molten stone

Alternatives considered

none

Additional context

already added all of it up there

  • Confirm you have checked the roadmap, what's new, and the FAQ for your issue
commented

You did not explain why it matters that you cannot melt stone tools. You cannot melt wooden tools either, by the logic in the suggestion should we add molten wood as well?

More importantly, what would molten stone do other than be confused with seared stone and lava?


Regarding getting seared stone, have you considered maybe we don't want bigger smelteries to be free? There are plenty of ways for you to produce a lot of seared stone (including melting certain mobs), so I would rather not give it to you for a block as cheap as cobblestone.

commented

In 1.12.2 version when you melt cobblestone or store you get shared brick in ingot cast and shared stone in block cast. It was easy to mage bigger smeltery how it works in 1.16 i dont know. Wait for someone else

commented

Wheres the link ?

commented

Wooden tools would burn there anyway, so it would be useless.

commented

No, i dont wanna get seared stone, molten stone.

commented

like stone but molten

commented

you could cast stone into the cauldrons from tinkers

commented

and bricks from ingots

commented

You did not explain why it matters that you cannot melt stone tools. You cannot melt wooden tools either, by the logic in the suggestion should we add molten wood as well?

More importantly, what would molten stone do other than be confused with seared stone and lava?

Regarding getting seared stone, have you considered maybe we don't want bigger smelteries to be free? There are plenty of ways for you to produce a lot of seared stone (including melting certain mobs), so I would rather not give it to you for a block as cheap as cobblestone.

Its because you cant trash them normally. wooden tools you can

commented

like smelting with them.

commented

Stone tools you need to burn

commented

in fire

commented

Github is not discord. Please post complete thoughts in a single comment rather than spamming comments.

It sounds to me like your idea is not super thought out yet. I suggest joining the SlimeKnights discord (was linked on the new issues screen) and we can discuss it further there. Overall I still don't see a need for melting stone just so you can recycle stone tools. They cost all of 3 cobblestone, which you can get in less time than it takes to melt the tools.

commented

Its basically how i say it, molten stone, stone melted by lava. what else would you imagine ?

commented

a gray molten stone.