Necrotic bone is missing forge:bones/wither tag
Closed this issue · 5 comments
Minecraft Version
1.20.1
Forge Version
47.4.2
Mantle Version
1.11.61
Tinkers' Construct Version
3.10.1.76
Problem description
Some mods like architects palette use the forge:bones/wither tag for crafting and apply it to their own wither bones, however tinkers does not use this for necrotic bones.
Suggested solution
Add the tag to necrotic bones so you can craft architects palettes blocks with them.
Alternatives considered
It might also be worth while consuming the tag for crafting recipes as well.
Additional context
Searched for existing enhancement?
Used the search bar
Its in wither_bones, that's the original tag people used for it. When did people change the tag for the item we invented?
There isn't a bone hierarchy so the nested tag didn't make sense.
Which other mods are currently doing bones like this? Affects how I attempt to fix this.
Trivial solution is just nesting one of the tags inside the other, but I can't do that if someone else is also nesting the opposite direction.
Could also just make a local tag that contains both forge tags for use in recipes, and then talk to other modders using this tag to see which we want to keep.
The mod in my instance using it is Architects palette.
WAIFU reveals that there are quite a few mods who use it:
- Ice and Fire iceandfire:witherbone
- Architect's Palette architects_palette:withered_bone
- Mo' Shiz Mod ms:materials/wither_bone
- Ice and Fire iceandfire:witherbone
- Tinkers' Integrations and Tweaks tconstruct:necrotic_bone
- Tinkers' Integrations and Tweaks iceandfire:witherbone
- Gelaria gelaria:witherbone
Including one who adds tconstructs one to it lol.
For forge:wither_bones there aren't as many, but some add to it from the bones/wither tag and one who just... adds everyone elses bones to it. WAIFU search:
- Baubley Heart Canisters bhc:wither_bone
- Wither Bones wither_bones:wither_bone
- Vanilla Boom vanillaboom:wither_bone
- Tinkers' Construct tconstruct:necrotic_bone
- Hostile Mobs and Girls #forge:bones/wither
- Hostile Mobs and Girls iceandfire:witherbone
- Hostile Mobs and Girls mna:witherbone
- Hostile Mobs and Girls legendary_monsters:withered_bone
- Hostile Mobs and Girls eternalnether:withered_bone
- Hostile Mobs and Girls netherex:wither_bone
- Ice and Fire iceandfire:witherbone from #forge:bones/wither
- Architect's Palette architects_palette:withered_bone from #forge:bones/wither
Just to make sure I understand you correctly, you are saying many people add the tag forge:bones/wither to forge:wither_bones? But no one adds in the other direction?
That would suggest the solution is to continue using forge:wither_bones for our recipes, and just add our bone to the other tag for people who want the less clear tag. I call it less clear as I am under the assumption no one adds wither bones to forge:bones, its certainty not a place our bone belongs as I always assumed that tag is for "normal" bones.