This is Waystones 1.14.4-5.1.1

I have crafted a set of Bound Scrolls. Separate the stack, sneak-right-click on a waystone, and that waystone's name will appear on the tooltip. Use the scroll like a bow, and the scroll will teleport you to that waystone.

The problem is that if you travel via waystone, the scrolls rebind to the destination waystone instead of the one the player told it to be bound to. This seems pointless if it just teleports you to where you already are, instead of where you wanted to be able to go back to.

"Use a return scroll" is NOT the solution. What I am trying to do is give someone else a destination that they do not already have activated. The other person using a return scroll will not accomplish this.

Turns out this is user error. I am literally doing it wrong.