Improved Fire Overlay
Julienraptor01 opened this issue · 7 comments
Mod name
Improved Fire Overlay
Curseforge link
https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/improved-fire-overlay
Other links
https://github.com/RuffleSteels/Improved-Fire-Overlay
What it does
This client-side fabric mod makes it so that when you and other entities are set fire by a soul flame, the overlay is correct and blue !
Why should it be in the modpack
BugFix but...
Why shouldn't it be in the modpack
The "bug" kinda mak sense when you think a bit more
I would expect mobs to burn orange regardless of whether they are positioned in soul fire or normal fire. Soul Soil is what burns blue. Netherrack and other substances burn orange. Soul Soil is used to create soul fire torches. I agree with jonathan schaudt.
A ghast could fire an orange-burning ball, setting soul soil ablaze blue. Anything the blue fire catches should burn orange unless it is crafted from soul soil or is a "soul mob".
Categories
Graphics optimization, New feature, Fixes a bug/makes another mod work
Additional details
No response
If it's a bug, why not report it here? (Debugify patch request)
If it's a bug, why not report it here? (Debugify patch request)
I found the bug on mojang's tracker and the fire act like this both on java and on bedrock.
https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC-170828
https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE-66081
Yes it could be reported to debugify and the other bugfix mods
However here is a quote of one of the bug comment which make sense
I would expect mobs to burn orange regardless of whether they are positioned in soul fire or normal fire. Soul Soil is what burns blue. Netherrack and other substances burn orange. Soul Soil is used to create soul fire torches. I agree with jonathan schaudt.
A ghast could fire an orange-burning ball, setting soul soil ablaze blue. Anything the blue fire catches should burn orange unless it is crafted from soul soil or is a "soul mob".
Now that i think a bit more of it the color of the fire is logic
Now that I think a bit more of it the color of the fire is logic
True, should we wait for Mojang to fix it?
I think as this is opinated, yes
But i've seen kingbdogz assign the issue to himself at least 2 times and the bug as been set at low priority so it's kinda recognized as a bug but mojang have in the past said "This thing is a bug !" and after many years " This, a bug ? No it's a feature !"
Now that I think a bit more of it the color of the fire is logic
True, should we wait for Mojang to fix it?
I think as this is opinated, yes
But i've seen kingbdogz assign the issue to himself at least 2 times and the bug as been set at low priority so it's kinda recognized as a bug but mojang have in the past said "This thing is a bug !" and after many years " This, a bug ? No it's a feature !"
👍 , this issue should either be marked as "on hold" or be closed I think
This mod is currently misleading so i'm gonna close temporarily and suggest a change to the dev
https://discord.com/channels/859124104644788234/976426574809296928/976459857433604166
RuffleSteels/Firorize#8
